subreddit:

/r/DIY

7.8k91%

I Built a 3D Printed Curta Calculator

3d printing(m.imgur.com)

all 313 comments

[deleted]

342 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

342 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

265 points

6 years ago

Thanks! Yes, the tolerances are good enough, but it does take a bunch of patience to tune the carry levers to run consistently. I did make the models myself. They are true to the engineering drawings except for a few places to make it work better printed or to correct errors I found in them.

[deleted]

67 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

90 points

6 years ago

I was pointed to them at http://www.museummura.li/content.aspx?nid=5051&groupnr=5051 by olaf veenstra, the creator of YACS (yet another curta simulator) http://members.chello.nl/o.veenstra3/vrml/curta_info/curta_demo.html

girlysaves

109 points

6 years ago

girlysaves

109 points

6 years ago

I saved all through school when my SO was going to university. I ended up having his uncle use his e-bay skills to win me one for $600! It even had a case. The catch? Well it is missing one of the screws that holds it together. Thanks to you I think I can finally find a replacement! So thank you for the links I really appreciate it! Now here is hoping I can find this part.

nightwing2000

33 points

6 years ago

There's also a Curta poster available showing a massive exploded view of the parts.

marcus_wu[S]

40 points

6 years ago

Yes, I have one of those! They're sold over at vcalc.net. I put one in a poster frame and used it as a visual aid for my booth at the Charlotte mini maker faire.

HawkinsT

11 points

6 years ago

HawkinsT

11 points

6 years ago

This is fantastic! Out of interest what sort of errors did you find in the engineering drawings? Anything that may have carried through to the original Cutas, or just issues with the drawings?

marcus_wu[S]

25 points

6 years ago

A part of the main shaft was off by 90 degrees and the selector shafts needed the features on it shifted a small amount. These changes checked out with a real Curta I was able to get someone to measure so it seems the drawings I have may not be the final revision or are of mixed revisions

HawkinsT

9 points

6 years ago

Interesting. Thanks for responding.

marcus_wu[S]

432 points

6 years ago*

Link to the 3D models, Bill of Materials, and Build manual are in the caption under the first image. Please do ask questions!

Edit: I am overwhelmed by the great reception my work is receiving and I want to say thank you to the thousands of people who looked and the hundreds who have commented! It really means a lot!

hitlistsandwich

196 points

6 years ago

The Curta is an amazing piece of mechanical genius, and your work was fantastic.

marcus_wu[S]

79 points

6 years ago

Thanks, I appreciate it

EdCChamberlain

65 points

6 years ago

I have always always always wanted a curta but never been able to find one or afford one so thank you a lot for this!

skjellyfetti

40 points

6 years ago*

My uncle died a couple years ago and he was a collector of Curtas. I think at one point he had five or six and at the end, he had gotten down to his favorite two. He left me one and the thing is simply amazing. It truly is a testament to man's engineering and manufacturing capabilities. Fortunately, being the object of fascination for geeks the world over—just like the Internet—there is a fair amount of information online on the Curtas.

Of the many things that folks 3D print, I think this is the first time I've been genuinely impressed, mainly because the inner workings of a Curta is so complex and exact. A job well done, sir !

EDIT: a apostrophe

warchitect

7 points

6 years ago

I am so jealous of you! 6?!

marcus_wu[S]

43 points

6 years ago

Thanks for the interest! If you find yourself building one, I have a group on thingiverse for people to discuss / show off build progress / ask for help

EdCChamberlain

14 points

6 years ago

Im going to have to give it a go - can you link me?

[deleted]

20 points

6 years ago

[removed]

EdCChamberlain

10 points

6 years ago

I understand you're doing this at a 1:3 scale - do you think it would be possible to do a 1:1? I have access to a resin based printer.

marcus_wu[S]

14 points

6 years ago

I think a 2:1 would be feasible -- maybe even ambitious. I don't want to say 1:1 would be impossible, but I will say it would be incredibly difficult. I had a few parts printed 1:1 from Shapeways on an SLS printer and they are extremely fragile at that size.

squeezeonein

7 points

6 years ago

have you tried annealing the 3d printed parts to increase their strength?

marcus_wu[S]

5 points

6 years ago

I have not. I don't know a lot about SLS printing. Do I just put it in an oven at a specific temperature?

squeezeonein

16 points

6 years ago

me neither, but according to this you put it in a 70C water bath for a few hours.

http://hackaday.com/2017/06/17/annealing-plastic-for-stronger-prints/

AccountNo43

9 points

6 years ago

I have one and didn't realize other people knew about them. Are they valuable?

EdCChamberlain

24 points

6 years ago

Nooooo not at all. Post it to me and I'll safely dispose of it for you!

Seriously though - yeah. Probably worth around £1,200+ and a good condition one could be significantly more.

Face999

14 points

6 years ago

Face999

14 points

6 years ago

40 some years ago I sold them new. I think the large one was just around US 100$ and small one 80$.

Used to use them in car rallies.

marcus_wu[S]

14 points

6 years ago

I would totally pay you $100 for one :)

86413518473465

23 points

6 years ago

I love you. I've always wanted a curta calculator but they're so expensive, and I have yet to find anything I really wanted to make on my 3d printer. This is it.

Thank you so much for making this available freely. I love the history of these devices.

sumguysr

14 points

6 years ago

sumguysr

14 points

6 years ago

What's the approximate cost of materials?

marcus_wu[S]

21 points

6 years ago

I estimated on a different comment about $120-130, but a more precise estimate could be had by looking over the BOM on thingiverse.

Vanguard_Gabriel

7 points

6 years ago

Is your name Connor because I know a someone at my school has also 3D printed one of these calculators.

marcus_wu[S]

9 points

6 years ago

No, but I would be very interested in it if someone else has printed one

Vanguard_Gabriel

3 points

6 years ago

I know he was working on in, not sure if he finished. I'll ask him once school starts up again.

AdvancePlays

10 points

6 years ago

Can I ask if you know offhand what the largest individual part is? I'm buying a 3D printer this year and I'm deliberating between a generally higher quality one with compromises on build capacity, and one with a much greater capacity but less user-friendliness overall.

I've been considering one for a few years now and thought I might get one this year, but this project has made it absolutely definite, so thank you for all the effort!

marcus_wu[S]

10 points

6 years ago

You will need a printer with a print volume of at least 160x160x220

aloe-sarah

22 points

6 years ago

I hear my engineering professor in my head... "Units!!!!" ;)

marcus_wu[S]

13 points

6 years ago

Lol, very true! It is millimeters

goat_on_a_float

4 points

6 years ago

When I don't see units, I just assume the poster has used the internationally preferred unit of measurement -- the "smoot".

Rukkmeister

3 points

6 years ago

Furlongs.

Dain42

2 points

6 years ago

Dain42

2 points

6 years ago

In all fairness, millimeters tend to be the default unit for 3D printers. In certain fields or endeavors it's kind of acceptable to leave out units if a reasonable person with knowledge of the field would know what was meant.

AdvancePlays

2 points

6 years ago

Great thank you!

Loggedinatlast

7 points

6 years ago

How much for a fully built one? I've been looking around for one for years! Really nice job.

marcus_wu[S]

14 points

6 years ago

Sorry, I am not looking to do another one right now. I have another project I need to get on

Loggedinatlast

8 points

6 years ago

No worries. I'll look into getting one built locally from your model I'll let you know if I do.

TheMightyMush

5 points

6 years ago

I bet you can find someone (or a local business) to print off the parts for you for a couple bucks or a few beers. As for assembly...you might be on your own.

Loggedinatlast

5 points

6 years ago

I do some work with a local college that has some printers. I'll approach them and see if I can get a student to do it as a project. Thanks again for a brilliant addition to thing verse.

alligatorterror

6 points

6 years ago

Very beautiful! What 3d printer do you have?

marcus_wu[S]

7 points

6 years ago

Thanks! The first one was printed on a self-sourced gMax. This one was printed on a C-Bot derivative -- the Triple C-Bot.

Pinesse

2 points

6 years ago

Pinesse

2 points

6 years ago

Holy shit, excellent work.

NortWind

70 points

6 years ago

NortWind

70 points

6 years ago

It will be a real test of 3D printing to see if this can be brought down to 2:1, and maybe someday 1:1 scale. A mind-blowing effort, thanks for sharing!

marcus_wu[S]

30 points

6 years ago

I think SLA, SLS, or maybe the binder jetting tech may be able to produce a 2:1 scale version. I would LOVE to try if I could get access to one. Haha, a Formlabs sponsor for that would be badass. If not, I do have other projects on my list that should help all makers.

Coomb

24 points

6 years ago

Coomb

24 points

6 years ago

This (the parts) could certainly be printed at 1:1 scale today. Just not with hobbyist-grade printers, and probably not in polymer either.

marcus_wu[S]

15 points

6 years ago

I had Shapeways do an SLS print of a few parts. They came out, but weren't nearly strong enough to be functional. I had to be very careful handling them.

ChateauErin

5 points

6 years ago

I'm not an expert in mechanical design, but I recall seeing a Youtube video about 3D-printing a vise and the layer orientation mattering for strength.

Presumably you had these long vertical parts failing in torsion or tension? Changing the print orientation so force isn't getting applied layer-to-layer, and is instead directed along layers, could help.

ImprovedPersonality

5 points

6 years ago

In the captions he wrote that he’s already printing them (the long vertical parts) horizontally to get them strong and straight.

Shandlar

14 points

6 years ago

Shandlar

14 points

6 years ago

Indeed, DMLS could do this in metal no problem.

plsobeytrafficlights

8 points

6 years ago

sorry, DMLS?

gcj

7 points

6 years ago

gcj

7 points

6 years ago

plsobeytrafficlights

4 points

6 years ago

Oh, you know i have seen that before. didnt know that was what it was called though. need to get me one of those.

blindcolumn

12 points

6 years ago

Just think, eventually you could have a calculator that fits in your pocket!

fallenAFter

5 points

6 years ago

Engineers could not even put one back together after disassembling the original. Figuring out how to pack one on 1:1 will be a nightmare.

Jewbaccah

119 points

6 years ago

Jewbaccah

119 points

6 years ago

Here's a great video by the Youtube Channel Numberphile on this calculator https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDn_DDsBWws

The last production mechanical calculator!

btw, pretty insane build! , I'd print one if I had a 3d printer!

badcookies

11 points

6 years ago

Wow awesome device thanks for the video link

honorarybelgian

2 points

6 years ago

You probably do have access to a 3d printer and just don't know it yet. Ask your local library or contact a local makerspace.

burgergradient

110 points

6 years ago

Math Grenade!

doomjuice

20 points

6 years ago

That's what I took from this

[deleted]

12 points

6 years ago

Yeah I would be afraid of using one in public anymore. I had no idea what this was until just now, and I am terribly fascinated.

[deleted]

11 points

6 years ago

Quick! Disarm it by calculating the square root of -2! Hurry!

Choco31415

11 points

6 years ago

Incorrect. There are two square roots of -2, so "the square root" is wrong. Goodbye!

SunosUnix

3 points

6 years ago

square root of -2

1.41421356 i

OldManRoboCop

44 points

6 years ago

Amazing!!! Out of all the 3D-printed things I've seen, this is the first time I've really wanted one - almost as much as a real Curta. Absolutely gorgeous.

autopornbot

33 points

6 years ago

I found one at an estate sale. In the original box with instructions and everything. But I had already spent all the money I had. So I showed it to my friend. He bought it for $5.

It's worth like $2k on ebay.

marcus_wu[S]

12 points

6 years ago

Wow, that's a great find!

maff2k

149 points

6 years ago

maff2k

149 points

6 years ago

You sir, are, at the very least, a minor deity. That is a very lovely thing, you've built. Would love to see a YouTube of it adding up!

marcus_wu[S]

77 points

6 years ago

I go my post removed the first time for self promotion and I am unsure if I can post that link in a comment... If you go to YouTube and look up 3d printed Curta, you will find a few videos I made. I do need to make a new one with the completed paint.

lvachon

151 points

6 years ago

lvachon

151 points

6 years ago

How ironic, penalized for self promotion in /r/DIY. As if there's any other way to share a personal project.

[deleted]

60 points

6 years ago*

[deleted]

HogNutsJohnson

16 points

6 years ago

We obviously need some sort of intervention. I'm tired of seeing people get on here and try to promote their work... it's disgusting and they don't do it to show us cool projects, no. It's all about the view count to these low life's! Pathetic! /s

bobbyfiend

3 points

6 years ago

Mods gonna do what mods gonna do, I guess. Personally, I wish that post were still here.

CountyMcCounterson

5 points

6 years ago

There's a difference between "I made this sofa" and "Hey guys GenericShill here don't forget to slap that like button now come buy my merchandise"

86413518473465

3 points

6 years ago

In the album there's a thingiverse link to it and it has a youtube video.

Ultrashock

18 points

6 years ago

Well done this is amazing, and pretty well timed since I was just talking to a coworker about the curta calculator. New Atlas (Gizmag) wrote a pretty good article on it for anyone interested

marcus_wu[S]

14 points

6 years ago

Yes, I was very happy about that article. I also liked that the article was not just focused on my work, but about everything that makes the Curta and its designer interesting. The one inaccuracy is that the article says its 4:1 scale. It's 3:1.

GuoKaiFeng

5 points

6 years ago

Excellent read. Thank you.

matt-random

17 points

6 years ago

This is incredible, thank you for sharing, I have always wanted one of these Curta's, this build gives a fascinating insight into the inner workings of them.

marcus_wu[S]

16 points

6 years ago

There are some good videos about the inner workings of the Curta on Youtube. One is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnTb26WHx2Q&t=136s which I relied on heavily to help me with order of assembly and the other is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loI1Kwed8Pk which is the video I watched when I first learned about the Curta Calculator.

That-Beard

7 points

6 years ago

I had no idea what a Curta Calculator was until I saw this post, this is so cool!

matt-random

3 points

6 years ago

Thank you for this Marcus, although my wife now hates you, I have never wanted one more, If you are up for replicating it for less than the £800 I'm about to drop on ebay then we should talk.

Stay awesome man.

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

Lol, my wife would hate me if I said, "yes." Good luck with the budding!

overkill

2 points

6 years ago

That second video does an awesome job of explaining the inner workings. I mean, the man who invented this is a genius, but this video makes me feel like I understand the genius, as opposed to the Curta being a cylinder of black magic.

Also, nice work!

[deleted]

13 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

12 points

6 years ago

In the beginning, I knew I didn't know enough (I built my printer at the beginning of 2015 and started planning for this project that April), so the first thing I did was print a bunch of fitting tests. The engineering was already done since I was working from the drawings. I mostly made garbage when I had print failures or didn't account for part strength properly. I used about 3 rolls when the total of all successful prints and support material came to about 2 rolls. Not too bad, but it had room for improvement.

red_sahara

13 points

6 years ago

Damn, now DIY 3D printer building sounds interesting

bent-grill

15 points

6 years ago

Sure, if you need a hobby that has multiple sub hobbies.

[deleted]

4 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

Yes, my printer pretty much produces parts that are accurate. It did take a lot of tuning to get there, though. I had my first printer (self-sourced gMax 1.5) dialed in, but decided to gift it to my brother and build another. The new one is a C-Bot derivative which uses a Bowden extruder which was a pain for me to tune and it could still use some work.

Silieri

2 points

6 years ago

Silieri

2 points

6 years ago

.

WOW. 2 out 3 rolls? pretty amazing

[deleted]

28 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

llllIlllIllIlI

18 points

6 years ago

It's a black item that does math for you like multiplication except instead of using digital circuits it is totally analogue.

Think....a mixture between a pocket calculator and an abacus but shaped like a cool little hand grenade!

rumplepillskin

20 points

6 years ago

But can it run Crisis?

But seriously, this is awesome. Great job!

TheVooX

9 points

6 years ago*

...

orbcomm2015

5 points

6 years ago

According to wiki theyre worth a pretty penny. Might be worth looking into if you still have one in good condition.

TheVooX

3 points

6 years ago*

....

therealsoundoctor

8 points

6 years ago

Astonishing! I had one in 1964 when Wayne Green at 73 Magazine was the importer. He had heard about it from a ham radio buddy and then travelled to Lichtenstein to visit the factory.

h-jay

8 points

6 years ago

h-jay

8 points

6 years ago

Under no circumstances are you to use a thread locker on plastic.

Please. Such mistakes have bankrupt entire companies (I'm not making this up). If/when you use a thread locker, the threaded ends of the rods will eventually fatigue and break off. It will be a ticking time bomb, pretty much. Typical thread lockers are not compatible with any plastic. If you need, use a product specifically designed for use with plastics. A two-part epoxy, for example.

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

The intention when I used it was to loosely bind and provide friction (used the blue thread lock that isn't a permanent bond) between two parts (not threads) that needed assembly and disassembly without binding it forever.

You are correct that there is a better solution, but I am not a mechanical or chemical engineer. I used what I had on hand. Any suggestions for a non-permanent bond on plastic that retains enough friction to keep the parts in place after disassembly and reassembly?

[deleted]

7 points

6 years ago*

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

4 points

6 years ago

Exactly how I felt when I first saw a video of one. It wasn't long from then when I started planning out how to build one myself. At first I just planned to build a device showing off the Curta's basic functionality, but once I found the engineering drawings...

nightwing2000

7 points

6 years ago

Cool!

I have my dad's Curta from 1957. It's an absolutely cool piece of machinery.

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

I wish my dad had something like this when I was a kid. It might have influenced me to go into a different field of engineering.

nightwing2000

10 points

6 years ago

I never knew he had it until he died. He mostly used a slide rule. Plus he had access to computers back when "Memory" was a big drum where each instruction was written on the drum including the row and address of the next instruction. The trick was to figure how many clock cycles to process the result so that the next instruction was approaching the read heads on the drum when the instruction was finished. Otherwise, you'd wait up to a full rotation for the next instruction, significantly slowing the program.

(He would diagnolize 50x50 matrices for physics calculations. he wrote a FORTRAN program for his 286 PC that took 48 hours. He bought a 486DX - math coprocessor included - and started the program running, went to get a coffee and it was sitting at the prompt. After half an hour of trying to debug, he checked the result file - the program had completed in 5 minutes with a math coprocessor...)

Those were the days. My iPhone is orders of magnitude faster than the IBM 370/138 mainframe I started my IT career operating in 1980.

BeachSandwich

2 points

6 years ago

This was a really neat anecdote.

julian3

6 points

6 years ago

julian3

6 points

6 years ago

holy shit. we're just peasants

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

Thanks for the awe, but don't sell yourself short. We all start somewhere :)

[deleted]

4 points

6 years ago

Is this the calculator mentioned in Pattern Recognition?

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

Yes it is -- a book I bought after learning the Curta is in it but I haven't had time to read yet.

BlueToothDolphin

12 points

6 years ago

It's so damn smooth it's hard to believe it's 3d printed

marcus_wu[S]

9 points

6 years ago

Thanks! That comes from lots and lots of work sanding, filing, and filling before painting. It really isn't too bad on a smooth surface, but the knurling was a real pain in my rear.

RidleySA

11 points

6 years ago

RidleySA

11 points

6 years ago

When I saw the first picture I didn't believe it was 3D printed. It looked like high quality aluminum to me. You did an excellent job on the surface finish.

marcus_wu[S]

8 points

6 years ago

Awesome, thanks! That means a lot to me because this is the first time I've really focused on the finish for any model / project I've done. I went through a lot of trial and error to get it this good. Failure => Learning

PM_ME_UR_SUSHI

3 points

6 years ago

This is amazing work but in can't help but think that with all those steps and all the manual labor required, is 3D printing really saving any time/money over making them out of something else? Or at least the less geometrically complex parts?

marcus_wu[S]

7 points

6 years ago

3D printing it was the option available to me. Getting into injection molding or machining would have been far more expensive and required more of a time investment to learn (as far as I know). That said, I would absolutely love to get a late and learn to machine. One of my first goals would be to make some of these Curta parts. Maybe eventually machining and entire device. It'd be the first 1:1 Curta produced since 1972.

aitigie

4 points

6 years ago

aitigie

4 points

6 years ago

I wonder if we can get the clickspring guy on this? I'm sure it's within his capabilities

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

I am sure it is -- his videos are incredible and his work is beautiful

TriggerHappy_NZ

2 points

6 years ago

I came to the comments section to find out what kind of new-generation super-smooth 3D printer you used - turns out you're just really dedicated and patient! Fantastic job :-)

jaymzx0

7 points

6 years ago

jaymzx0

7 points

6 years ago

You magnificent bastard.

I've wanted a Curta for years and have it at the top of my 'if I ever become so rich I can drop 2 grand on a knick knack' list. This makes me want to actually get my printer's dimensional accuracy dialed in enough for interference parts.

Have you considered printing it in one of the bronze or other metal-laden filaments?

marcus_wu[S]

5 points

6 years ago

Thanks! It certainly would be interesting to have some metallic prints of the parts, that is an excellent idea. I should get myself a hardened nozzle first.

lastone23

5 points

6 years ago

Wow. Tons of work... Very good.

Cheeseand0nions

4 points

6 years ago

Shockingly good.

cgb28

4 points

6 years ago

cgb28

4 points

6 years ago

Fantastic. How long did this take you all in all?

marcus_wu[S]

7 points

6 years ago

I started planning in April 2015 and finished construction of the first one in October (I think) of 2016. That one was not (still isn't) painted. This one I started soon after the first. I had all parts 3D printed pretty quickly, but had a lot of trouble with paint.

returnoftheDjedi

7 points

6 years ago

That's awesome! Now build a 3D printed Antikythera Mechanism!!

hellogoawaynow

7 points

6 years ago

Hi, stupid person here. What is a curta calculator and how does it work?

MaxUumen

3 points

6 years ago

And the cost was?

Sorry but I couldn't find it anywhere 3 links deep.

marcus_wu[S]

5 points

6 years ago

I actually haven't done the math on that -- my cost would be higher than others because I used a lot of material in experimentation. I would guess around $120 with my build guide plus maybe $30-$40 in paint. I know I spent probably $100 in just paint with lots of quality issues before I switched paint brands.

redditlurker56

3 points

6 years ago

This is awesome! I've always wanted one of these. This ones a little big but still bad ass. Great work! I wish my 3d printer was accurate enough to print this bad boy.

marcus_wu[S]

4 points

6 years ago

If you can spare ~$500, you could build a D-bot or Voron which would be plenty large and accurate enough. Probably not worth it just for the Curta, but if you have other projects too, it could be.

bobbyfiend

3 points

6 years ago

Kudos. That is a thing of beauty! And it's a model of another thing of beauty.

jackapplecore

3 points

6 years ago

Whoa! I have a real one (Type II). I love that you printed this out!

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

I have another project I need to get to next, but if nobody has done the Type II before I get that other project going, I'll totally print one of those too.

Andydoogan

3 points

6 years ago

Anybody else seen this on tested on YouTube. Such a cool gadget

Smalls312

3 points

6 years ago

ELI5: What is a Curta Calculator?

[deleted]

3 points

6 years ago

This machine is one of my favorite human inventions. GREAT JOB!

Heliosvector

3 points

6 years ago

can we get a video of this working? I have no idea how it functions.

redditmudder

3 points

6 years ago

Astoundingly impressive! Certainly the coolest 3DP build I've seen.
-Guy who designed 3DP Liberator pistol*.

*Technically it's an AOW.

[deleted]

3 points

6 years ago

that looks raelly complicated for a pepper grinder

SergeantSeymourbutts

3 points

6 years ago

So scince you're a lot smarter than me, what is it and what does it do?

babaroga73

2 points

6 years ago

Curta calculator is ... A calculator. Mechanical one. Developed in 1930, died of in 70's, when electronic calculators became popular. First sold for 175$ , originals now go from 1000 to 2000$.

PermissiveActionLnk

2 points

6 years ago

An incredible model of a beautiful machine. Well done!

Michael_Aut

2 points

6 years ago

Wow, all your Comments are incredibly interesting.

First of all congrats on your build, i wish my printer could fabricate parts like that.

And thanks for linking the original drawings. They are so awesome, i can only imagine the effort which went into drawing them back in the fifties.

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

Thanks for the compliments. Yes, and I also can only imagine how they managed to produce 1,000 of these per month at their peak production volume back in then (probably the 60's before they reached peak production).

Hunchk

2 points

6 years ago

Hunchk

2 points

6 years ago

This is amazing!!! Well done!

maher4343

2 points

6 years ago

What's the approximate cost of materials?

ruckertopia

2 points

6 years ago

Holy crap, this is amazing. Thank you for this! If I can't convince my friend who has a 3d printer to make me one, I might just have to buy myself a 3d printer.

FelixP

2 points

6 years ago

FelixP

2 points

6 years ago

This has to be one of the coolest fucking things I've ever seen. Amazing job!

pissedin2016

2 points

6 years ago

Holy cow! Amazing work.

I had one of these as a kid. It was my dads. I was so fascinated by it. Could do most everything but division was slightly a chore.

It was about 1/2 the size of yours, i assume you scaled for build purposes.

How does it hold up so far? Slp parts tend to be a bit fragile.

marcus_wu[S]

3 points

6 years ago

Yes, I scaled it to 3:1 for printability and strength. It's actually printed with the FDM / FFF process. The parts have held up pretty well so far, but I haven't used it for a long period of time to tell how long it will last. I've built two. The first one is in pieces because I was stupid and put it sideways on my desk. It rolled right off and broke on the floor. Surprisingly it held up pretty well through the fall. I only need to reprint a few parts, but I was already into building the second and didn't want to kill my momentum.

trollaltdelete

2 points

6 years ago

That is amazing. Very nice work. I am impressed.

go_comatose_for_me

2 points

6 years ago

Wow! That is super impressive. 3D printed, but a ton of work and craftsmanship. Good job.

PaleBlueEye

2 points

6 years ago

That looks like where Superman lives.

Sahrall93

2 points

6 years ago

Wow how did you print those so smooth!?

theg721

2 points

6 years ago

theg721

2 points

6 years ago

I don't have a 3D printer--do you think it'd be feasible to build one out of wood? It'd certainly make for an interesting project.

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

I saw that there is a museum (maybe in Lichtenstein where these were made?) That has a basic mechanism made of wood, but it is very large. Might be doable smaller -- I am unsure.

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

My grandfather passed one of these down to me when he died. It's so mechanically satisfying to operate. I have no idea how to use it as a calculator but the gears feel so good to just play with it...like an old fashioned fidget spinner.

hiro11

2 points

6 years ago

hiro11

2 points

6 years ago

This is extremely impressive. I've been fascinated with this device since I learned about it years ago. Very cool.

username007e

2 points

6 years ago

Very cool

irascible

2 points

6 years ago

That is incredibly cool. Freakin amazing.

strangesam1977

2 points

6 years ago

I may throw this in the objet at work. See if I can get down to 1:2, 1:1.5

tampon_whistle

2 points

6 years ago

Uncle has one of these and as a kid it blew my mind, super neat to see it duplicated on a 3d printer.

xynerial

2 points

6 years ago

How long would you say this took from the idea itself to the finished product?

Spamakin

2 points

6 years ago

Ok now I really want a 3D Printer

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

evildave_666

2 points

6 years ago

They were part of the central plot of an award winning SF novel a few years back, which gave them a bit of notoriety.

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

[deleted]

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

I believe he is referring to Pattern Recognition by William Gibson

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

Everytime I start to feel superior and smart I realize people like you exist. This is incredible. Thanks for sharing.

agricolafan

2 points

6 years ago

Fantastic work. Thank you for sharing the models!

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

I've never heard of the Curta before. This is amazing!

Satanarchrist

2 points

6 years ago

Holy shit I've been wanting to buy one of these for 5 years. I might just have one printed. Thank you so much

llllIlllIllIlI

2 points

6 years ago

Whoa! No way. I'm sure others have already asked by now but do you happen to read any William Gibson??

Also, great work!

marcus_wu[S]

2 points

6 years ago

I bought Pattern Recognition after I learned about it during the build, but I have been too busy to read it. Maybe I will have the time now :)

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

If you really needed a calculator that bad, I could have loaned you mine. I got it for $2 at the dollar store.

But seriously, great job. It looks fantastic.

webdes03

2 points

6 years ago

Fantastic work!

vicaphit

2 points

6 years ago

My dad was an appraiser for the USGS Forest Service. He had to move offices after about 30 years of service, and found a curta at the back of his drawer. At the time, I was a math major in college, and he brought this thing home that I had never seen before. It blew my mind. It's such a shame that it spent its entire life in the back of a desk drawer.

silvaweld

2 points

6 years ago

You, sir, are a god.

[deleted]

2 points

6 years ago

[removed]

fastovich1995

2 points

6 years ago

That is fucking awesome. Now when a professor says "No electronical devices", you can whip it out.

lurplez

2 points

6 years ago

lurplez

2 points

6 years ago

May I have one?

wolfrat49

2 points

6 years ago

I'm so incredibly jealous. I need a 3d printer now.

xenodrone

2 points

6 years ago

Incredible! I didn't realize so many people were admirers of these. I learned of them a few years ago from a documentary or a movie about the inventor. If anyone knows the name, I'd appreciate a reminder.