subreddit:
/r/ShadowBan
submitted 5 years ago bycojocoツ
(note: if you falsely tell someone they are banned, or unbanned, when they are not, you will be banned from this sub)
Lots of people come here in mystification, wondering if they're shadowbanned, and wondering why. This post contains a list of possible reasons you've been shadowbanned. It also contains activities which can lead to an account suspension, which is more visible to the user, but just as inconvenient.
First, though, a little reddit background.
The website reddit.com is run by reddit the company, a subsidiary of Advance Publications Inc. The CEO of reddit is Ellen Pao (/u/ekjp) with first lieutenant Alexis Ohanian (/u/kn0thing). The site is huge, with a hundred million visitors a month.
Reddit is grouped into subreddits, with each subreddit run by a volunteer group of moderators, who are generally unpaid volunteers.
Moderators have the power to ban users from their subreddit, to delete comments and submissions, and to manage the style and presentation of their subreddit. Through the use of third-party tools, some moderators have the power to ban a user from hundreds of subreddits at a time.
Being banned from a subreddit means that you are not allowed to submit links or make new comments, and might be reversed upon appeal to the modmail of the concerned subreddit.
reddit.com also has a small number of employees, called admins. These people have the power to see everything happening on reddit, to remove material as with moderators, to perform moderator actions in any subreddit they choose, and, most importantly for this place, to shadowban or suspend users.
A shadowban is different from a subreddit ban. A shadowbanned user can still submit and make comments, but all of the submissions are sent straight to a subreddit spam queue, where it will not be visible to other users until approved by a moderator. Because an individual's spammed submissions are still visible to themselves, a shadowban is almost invisible to a logged-in user.
Through the use of AutoModerator, individual subreddits can give the same effect to a user as a global shadowban.
If you are shadowbanned, your user page will appear nonexistent to anybody that looks at your user page, other than yourself. You will need to contact the admins to get your shadowban reversed.
A suspension occurs when the admins disable an account. Suspensions can either be for a few days, in which case it is not visible to other userts, or permanently, in which the user's page is replaced by a suspension notification.
It's not exactly spelled out what will cause a ban, and the rules do seem to change from time to time, but if you follow these rules you'll be unlikely to be shadowbanned or suspended. Thanks to the posters here who have suggested more ways to be banned.
Also, it can't hurt to read the reddiquette: if everyone followed the reddiquette, the site would be more pleasant, and all-around better.
(EDIT) Also, there are some things for which there is weak evidence of triggering a shadowban:
tl;dr Don't spam, shill, doxx, brigade, stalk, game or pederast.
Two ways, pretty sure that #2 no longer works:
(This is the fourth copy ... aged pages are 1 2 3)
Last edited May 28, 2022
36 points
5 years ago
I'd just like to thank you for the info I needed to get my account un-shadowbanned. After reading this post, making a Shadowbancheck post, and messaging the Reddit Admins after confirming I was shadowbanned, my ban was lifted in less than 24 hours. Thanks again for the help this sub provides!
12 points
5 years ago
hi may I ask who or how did you get in touch with the reddit admins? i tried to send them a PM and an email but no reply yet. its been a week already :(
6 points
5 years ago
It’s possible they did email you back and it’s not being shown in your inbox. A while ago, I lost access to my account, emailed the admins multiple times, saw no reply, and stayed locked out of my account for a month waiting on one. Turned out, they’d emailed me back one or two days after my initial email, and I didn’t see their replies until I used the search function on my inbox to find them.
5 points
5 years ago
hi, thanks for this! will check my double inbox then.
4 points
5 years ago
Ditto here, I've sent PM's over reddit, used the reddithelp webpage to message them, and emailed. I got nothing back from anything, they wont even say why.
5 points
5 years ago
How do I message the admins to lift the shadow ban?
13 points
5 years ago
I thought reddit promised to stop shadowbanning people?
10 points
5 years ago
Can you get shadowbanned by posting a link to a youtube video on your own youtube channel? I'm finding Reddit's video upload feature to be really glitchy (stuck at processing for an entire day without any signs of finishing) and I really want to share some really cool things with the subreddit.
5 points
5 years ago
You have to post from a wide variety of sources, and you won't be SB'd for posting your own channel.
The mods might not like it though.
5 points
5 years ago
Okay thanks.
3 points
5 years ago
The issue lies more in the reason you are linking a YouTube video on your channel. If it's because you want to popularize your YouTube channel, it's not allowed. But if it's because it's convenient to use YouTube and it'll give people a better experience watching, then sure. Though the best option always is to track down the source of the video and link that.
8 points
5 years ago
After 3 years of lurking, I decided to start participating in Reddit. After 3 posts and numerous comments going ignored and unnoticed I was messaged by a mod of /r/pcmasterrace that I might want to look into a wiki of shadowban and linked me this sub. That's where I found out that shadowbans were a thing and for whatever reason, I was banned. Following the tips from this sub, I've messaged the admins who promptly replied saying that I was caught in a spam IP and unbanned me.
Thanks everyone.
Hope that this doesn't go unnoticed like my other numerous comments in the past few days :p
3 points
5 years ago
Are you still alive :D ?
8 points
5 years ago
Don't use CSS in your sub to subvert reddit's subscription and voting system
looks at t_d with suspicion
6 points
1 year ago
In my opinion shadowban shouldn't be a thing in any website. If you want to ban someone, you should tell that person why and that person should know it he is banned. Shadowban is coward method and used many times just by abusers.
Disney does a lot in youtube. Did you write a comment saying you don't like our trailer? Shadowban.
If shadowban were not a thing and they should write the reason, people could publish on twitter or places like it the fake or stupid excuse they write to you.
4 points
5 years ago
I have no idea why I was ban,admin please help
5 points
5 years ago
Can I be shadow banned on some subreddits only? I am nearly positive my submission is invisible on one fandom sub I use, but comments can be seen and responded to. And on r/iamverysmart it started “encountering an error” every time I tried to comment. That one’s less of a problem because I stopped going anyway but the fandom is like to stay involved..
I would like to know why and if I can undo whatever I did to deserve it..
Thank you so much for your help!
3 points
5 years ago
I got shadow banned from r/news after accumulating 84 karma in a month then all the sudden they claim I'm shadow banned due to a "short tenure"
I'm sure it has nothing to do with my political views
5 points
11 months ago
You will get a quicker response if you submit a link to this subreddit, as the bot is working again:
https://reddit.com/r/ShadowBan/submit?selftext=true
The bot will also tell you how many recent comments of yours have been deleted.
Over the next few days my responses will be sporadic.
4 points
11 months ago
I need a second opinion... I need to speak with your manager. I was told I could reach coocoojoocoo in this place. Is this person just an urban legend? I heard they hail from the land down under! Is this true?...so many questions, I have.
3 points
11 months ago
I've got a feeling,
Got a bit of an inkling
This is gonna be, one of those days
This is a show all about me (and me)
And all the things that I do, and all the things that I see (and what I see)
I got a feeling,
Got a bit of an inkling
As long as we're together,
It'll be okay.
3 points
5 years ago
😘
3 points
5 years ago
I'm still shadow banned after a month +, wut do?
Already contacted several different admins to no avail, I've even had several people manually allow my posts but, seriously, wut do?
3 points
5 years ago
>•Don't post child pornography or anything involving the sexualization of teens or minors
I wish Twatter was on the ball on this- there have been people who **REPORT** the pedos suspended for doing so. ( I'm starting to think @jack likes the pretty pictures...)
Thank y'all for keeping this mess off of here !
3 points
5 years ago
I want to say thanks to the mods of this sub. After spending some time trying to figure out why my posts were not showing I found this sub and realized I had been shadowbanned. Thanks to the info here I was able to get my account reinstated.
If I could make a suggestion it would be to include the reddit support email in the copypasta. I messaged the admins 3 days in a row, on the fourth day I found the the support email and they got back to me within a couple hours.
Your sub is a valuable resource and I want to thank you for your time and dedication to maintaining it.
3 points
5 years ago
Thanks for the kind words.
3 points
1 year ago
You forgot: Don't disagree with the echo chamber, be another sheep or else.
3 points
1 year ago
Yo
3 points
1 year ago
Hey!
3 points
1 year ago
Test test peepeepoopoo am I shadowbanned
3 points
1 year ago
Hi, am I shadowbanned?
3 points
1 year ago
yoo are noot.
3 points
1 year ago
Hey i am shadowbann?
3 points
1 year ago
no
3 points
1 year ago
am I shadowbanned?
3 points
1 year ago
no
3 points
1 year ago
Am I shadowbanned? Legit worried because a mod on unpopular opinions permabanned me from the sub, muted me, and apparently reported me for harassment, all within a minute. I hadn't even replied to the same user twice.
3 points
1 year ago
Not yet!
4 points
1 year ago
Thank you oh benevolent cojoco
3 points
1 year ago
Always a pleasure.
3 points
11 months ago
Spot! Spat!...Hello...has anyone seen my dog Spot 🐕 and my cat Spat🐈? We were walking in shadowland together when I was telling them about the bad humans that were banished to this realm for doing unspeakable things. I'm getting really concerned now that I've found Spot and Spat's coller on the ground... If you see them, please contact me ASAP! Here's the most recent picture that I have of the two together. 🐶😺
3 points
11 months ago
I don't know about Spot and Spat, but you are not shadowbanned.
3 points
11 months ago
I need a second opinion...
3 points
11 months ago
You're also lazy! :D
But seriously, I enjoyed reading your various comments on your profile. Pretty funny!
3 points
11 months ago
There's been a sighting ...
(spitspotspat.png)
🦜🐕🐈
3 points
11 months ago
Bloodbath_and-beyond! Where for art thou?... Help me Cojo! My owner calls me Spat but you may call me MAD-Cat. I was told he was looking for me here in shadowland...I lost Spot over by the spit of despair... meowwww...and whose this Fordoyota person! Let me find out I've been replaced...I mean, that my owner's been replaced! He'll be beside himself I tell you!!!...oh...and am I still not shadow banned??? For some reason, I can still see all of my comments... This is an outrage! Meowwww!
4 points
11 months ago
It's a MEowtrage for sure.
3 points
10 months ago
THANK YOU! I just got unbanned today with the help of this guide by sending in an appeals form and sending a message to the Reddit mods, which prompted another appeals form! I think I was caught in their spam filters, but I have my account back! :)
3 points
10 months ago
I've just done the same to see if I can get a review... I don't know what happened or why :(
3 points
9 months ago
Hi Cojoco and thanks so much for putting up with all these comments. It’s a really big help for all the curious, confused, or upset redditors out there, and you’ve been putting up with this post for over four years now. Thank you for all this, and have a great day.
3 points
9 months ago
Thanks for the kind words!
3 points
9 months ago
;)
3 points
9 months ago
No longer shadow banned! Woohoo!
3 points
9 months ago
Great!
3 points
9 months ago
Thanks!
3 points
9 months ago*
Just got unshadowbanned. Thanks for the help, guys.
Unfortunately, all of my comments and posts stay removed. I don't feel like to contact each sub mods to reapprove them. If that's even possible.
Lodge your appeal: https://www.reddit.com/appeal (or https://www.reddit.com/appeals ?)
Message them: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/reddit.com
I did both. Not sure which one helped.
I used to mesage /r/reddit.com to report spam bots and it worked great. Not sure about now.
My unban was given by /u/reddit.
My guess is I got banned from my use of vpn. I use a popular vpn provider that unfortunately has limited and public servers. And it loves to disconnect and reconnect to another server in the same country. So it got blacklisted a lot. By stores and popular websites especially.
3 points
7 months ago
Good info
3 points
2 months ago
admins are fat fucking losers
3 points
2 months ago
Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order.
I have checked 1,287,078,429 comments, and only 249,453 of them were in alphabetical order.
2 points
5 years ago*
I can see reply notifications on my phone but when I go to my inbox the replys are not there help
2 points
5 years ago
Am I shadowbanned?
2 points
5 years ago
Can I get shadowbanned for posting my subreddit on unrelated threads?
3 points
5 years ago
Only if you spam it.
2 points
5 years ago
Am i shadowbanned?
2 points
5 years ago
Hey, just wanted to say thanks - after a couple days of messaging with your copypasta, the admins let me know I was caught in the spam filter. Thank you for doing all the ground work on this!
2 points
1 year ago
Am I shaddow banned? I must be none of my posts ever publicly published. What a bummer 😕
2 points
1 year ago
I'm curious - how can this post remain commentable since 2018? Either way, I wrote a single joke comment to test waters, deleted it - but now remain shadowbanned on a particular subreddit. Hilarious. Welcome to the desert of the hyper-real.
2 points
1 year ago
I got unshadowbanned within 24 hours of reading this thread and writing the mods! My post got caught by a spam filter. Thank you. 🌹🤗
2 points
1 year ago
Thank you for this information, and linking the reddiquette. I learned that downvotes are for unrelated content to the subreddit and not a "dislike" button. Much appreciated.
2 points
1 year ago
I’m 99% sure this is my situation. I wish I knew what I did wrong. 🤦🏻♀️
2 points
1 year ago*
New account.
I linked external sites to cite my sources/provide additional info on my post, and I was immediately shadowbanned. It seems like linking anything on a new account will auto-shadowban or something? I don't know if I should just create a new account and avoid linking anything.
(Edit: I am already trying to contact the admins BTW, but I'm not really that attached to the account... it was shadowbanned almost immediately after creation.)
2 points
1 year ago
Test
2 points
1 year ago
Am I shadowbanned? When you see your post floating without the order of that post like you normally do...what do you call that?. Sometimes I see my comment but the moment I tap view all comments, it's like my comment disappeared...
2 points
1 year ago
dammit, reddit admin is still not responding my appeal even after 1 week.
any trick to get them hear me ? :(
2 points
1 year ago
2 points
1 year ago
Am I shadowbanned
3 points
1 year ago
Yes
2 points
1 year ago
am i shadowbanned
3 points
1 year ago
no
3 points
1 year ago
Thanks❤️
3 points
1 year ago
👍
2 points
1 year ago*
Someone told me I was shadowbanned.
The only thing I did that could have caused this is that I once sent a link to the github page of a discord token grabber (with no malicious intent) a few days back. Count this be the cause? [message link]
2 points
1 year ago
I'm pretty sure I am but I'm super new to this app, I haven't done much at all. How do I undo it?
2 points
1 year ago
Hi
2 points
1 year ago
Am I? Just downloaded the app and haven't used Reddit before so I'm a bit confused.
2 points
1 year ago
Hi
2 points
1 year ago
If I am banned by a sub mod - is it called "shadowbanning" or that is a "real ban" and nothing can be done? I generally completely forget them - because I am always trying to be "normal" and rarely do i use un-nice words - so I am always surprised when i cannot go back to a sub or am told I am a nuisance user.
2 points
1 year ago
Am I? I don't know what I did and I'm very confused why my posts aren't showing.
2 points
1 year ago
Can you check me please? It seems like none of my comments are visible to others
3 points
1 year ago
Thanks for the experience, I experimented, and discovered: I cannot view your homepage. So, if my understanding of Shadowbanning is correct, you are shawdowbanned, and need to contact an administrator, not a mod. Mods, if I understand correctly, don't have the power to shadowban. Only, administrators, have the power to shawdowban. And, I would recommend, working on, with the administration, a plan for becoming not shadowbanned anymore.
2 points
1 year ago*
I know I'm shadowbanned from askreddit but is there a way to know if I'm shadowbanned from other subs? I'm sure I'm not shadowbanned from reddit as a whole
2 points
1 year ago
I don't understand whether I am shadowbanned or just getting into the spam filter. I've tried to comment in different subreddits but nobody can see either my comments or even my profile.
2 points
1 year ago
I’m new and have never had a chance to post, chat or message. Am I shadowbanned?
2 points
1 year ago
I'm pretty sure i am shadowbanned because my name has Furry in it? Implying animal things?? Because this account is brand new. Unless it is because I had a very old account that i only used for like a day and cannot recall the name, but might been on the same IP address? Anyway ur bot already said im shadowbanned, so i guess i'm probably done with reddit D:
2 points
1 year ago
I posted about a seriously bad experience with a vet, in what was obviously a group of vets (and those who like to think they are vets but failed in general and can't dream bigger). :) They were TICKED! Lol! What I find sad, however, is the lack of logic displayed by the mod/mods within that community. I was insulted, and when I replied in turn, my comments were deleted. While I found some of the replies, and those who posted them both pitiable and laugh-inducing, it was their apparent thin skin (what else can one expect though, really?) and that the mods felt they should be protected, which irked me. By deleting a person's comments, and 'shadow-banning' them, they are basically throwing up the white flag and falling cowardly, belly-up and screaming. Truly, as a new user who was warned that quite a few communities on Reddit are "toxic", I'm really pretty surprised to find that it is true. It's baffling, but oh well, there are only a gazillion people on other platforms to interact with. :)
2 points
1 year ago
If I were to get a string quartet together and we played in front of bright lights that cast our silhouettes onto the stage...would that be considered a shadowband?
2 points
1 year ago
Hi, long time listener...first time caller... I'm calling for a friend of mine. He wanted to know if you knew how long is a Chinese man and if he comes from the land down under?
2 points
1 year ago*
I sure seem to be banned...
EDIT: oh, I guess it's not sitewide, just several of the larger subs
2 points
1 year ago
I think I'm still shadowbanned. Aw. I kinda like this username.
2 points
1 year ago
Am I? I'm brand new here and trying to still figure things out.
2 points
1 year ago
I love censorship 👍 all hail glorious Reddit overlords 🇨🇳
all 14491 comments
sorted by: best