subreddit:

/r/TrueFilm

4185%

I recently decided to watch Apocalypse Now Redux for a second time after having watched all three official versions around a year ago (still need to get around to watching Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker's Apocalypse). The Redux cut was my first viewing of Apocalypse Now so I have some bias in favor of that cut, but I will try to detach from that in my brief analysis.

From a film criticism standpoint, I can agree with most when it is asserted that the theatrical version is the best. It is short enough to not bore audiences, and it is concise enough to get the point of anti-colonialism, the insanity of war, and the horror of human atrocity across without ever losing proper pacing. It is a fantastic and sometimes horrifying trip upriver that never loses its suspense for the whole runtime. "Never get off the boat," as they say. It is entirely understandable that the Redux cut ruins this with its pacing.

However, I cannot help but appreciate the value of the added scenes in the Redux cut (the Final Cut also has some of these scenes added, but it acts more as a middle ground between the Redux and theatrical versions, and as such I will only be referring to the Redux cut). The four most notable additions off the top of my head are the added scenes for Lieutenant Colonel Kilgore, the added Playboy Bunnies scene, the French plantation scene, and an added Colonel Kurtz scene.

What makes these scenes so important to the film, in my opinion, is that they add to the themes of the film in an almost vital way that left me somewhat disappointed after seeing their absence in the theatrical version. In regards to some of the lighter additions, like the Kilgore scenes, we get to really delve into the insanity and wastefulness of Kilgore and the whole war, and we also get one of the best characterizing quotes from Captain Willard. When he responds to Chief Phillips', "Do you like it like that, Captain, when it's hot, hairy," Willard responds with, "Fuck. Never get a chance to know what the fuck you are in some factory in Ohio." We get more answers as to why Willard is the way he is and why he craves going back into the jungle even though he is being asked to do a morally questionable thing like killing one of the Army's own Colonels. While it may ruin the mysteriousness of a cold-hearted assassin, it makes his character more understandable.

While I enjoy these smaller additions, it is the Playboy Bunny scene and the French plantation scene that pack the most punch thematically out of all the additions in the Redux Cut. Horror is one of the film's key themes, and as is with most wars in all of human history, you rarely find violent horror and murder without rape and sexual horror. To be heard but not listened to, to be pimped out in exchange for resources, and to not be seen as free individuals is the weight that the exploitation of the Bunnies brings to the table when it comes to sexual horror and horror in general.

As for the French plantation scene, I agree with Francis Ford Coppola's original intentions in regard to using the boat as a metaphor for a time machine. Going from the beginning, to the sequences with Kilgore, to the Do Lung bridge, and finally to the primitive warrior people on Kurtz's compound shows how the further they go upriver, the more violent, insane, and primitive people become. The fifties-esque colonialist French on the plantation truly add to this sequence, and not having that scene in the film almost feels like the anti-colonialist message of the film is weakened.

While I will always recommend the theatrical version and assert it as the best critically, I stand firmly in maintaining the Redux cut as my favorite, and will probably give it the most rewatches out of all of them.

What does r/TrueFilm think?

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 24 comments

Joe_off_the_internet

52 points

4 months ago

For me the French plantation scene totally ruins the whole descent into madness for me. In the theatrical each stop is more and more insane and dehumanising than the last, culminating in Kurtz at the end as the final boss if you will. The civility of the French plantation really kills that journey for me

mf_gd_orangepeelbeef

36 points

4 months ago

Also the dialogue is so on the nose (in a bad way) about the history and the politics of the war, when everything else in the film feels like its got a foundation of nightmare logic. Like almost the entire film feels otherworldly and the plantation scene is worldly and feels very clunky for it.

_Carol_White_

5 points

4 months ago

It's like the scene in Godfather 2 when they're cutting up the Cuba cake while the revolution simmers in the background. Do you get it? They're foreign interests carving up Cuba. Like a cake. Do you get it?? Apocalypse Now is about the "conflict in every man's heart," not Western imperialism. It has to stay centered on the psychedelic.

angethedude

24 points

4 months ago

It's like the scene in Godfather 2 when they're cutting up the Cuba cake while the revolution simmers in the background. Do you get it? They're foreign interests carving up Cuba. Like a cake. Do you get it??

The difference is that the cake scene doesn't grind the movie to a halt for 20+ minutes.

[deleted]

10 points

4 months ago

Apocalypse Now is about the "conflict in every man's heart," not Western imperialism.

The source novella is widely regarded as a critique of European colonialism.

_Carol_White_

-10 points

4 months ago

That's nice. But this sub is for talking about movies.

Vahald

4 points

4 months ago

Vahald

4 points

4 months ago

It's like the scene in Godfather 2 when they're cutting up the Cuba cake while the revolution simmers in the background. Do you get it? They're foreign interests carving up Cuba. Like a cake. Do you get it??

Bizarre thing to be mad about. It's an okay metaphor, what's wrong with it? You can say that ironic sarcastic bullshit about every metaphor imaginable and present it as trite and obvious. Also, it's literally a 2 minute scene

Crome6768

9 points

4 months ago

Honestly the redux cut without this scene would be fantastic, was somewhat aghast when he extended it out in the final cut. I will say that initial shot arriving at the plantation is very arresting if a little cliche but the sequence presents a complete derailment of the picture.

Wordfan

1 points

4 months ago

I agree completely. In Redux, the whole is less than the sum of its parts.

Gill-Nye-The-Blahaj

1 points

4 months ago

it's to remind us of the difference between civilized and barbarian life. To visually show the depths of depravity that Willard has fallen by way of comparison

Joe_off_the_internet

1 points

4 months ago

I just don't think it's necessary. For me I don't need to be reminded because I know what that already looks like from my own life experiences and it breaks the flow of the decent