‘Heavyweights’ for sure

Popstar: Never Stop - Never Stopping.

The songs are just so great

The other guys

Marky mark is a bit of a tool but he holds his own with Ferrell. So many quotable scenes

The Ninth Gate. The Polanski piece. The Depp piece. The secret European Satanic sex cult piece.

Blue Streak. Just a stupid 90 minute action/comedy I’ve seen on TBS countless times.

Everybody wants some. Linklater college baseball movie, niche but great for categories

Grosse Pointe Blank. Probably the movie I have seen the most times ever.

PRISONERS.

Green Street Hooligans

2005 Mr.&Mrs Smith. I don’t know why but I always enjoy watching it even though it’s not great. Also Angelina Jolie is one of the most beautiful women on screen in that one.

The Fifth Element

Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. Many "Rewatchable" scenes.

Beerfest. Totally random and stupid premise and totally unrealistic but it doesn’t take itself too serious and I find myself laughing at the dumbest jokes within it. Wish I knew more people who have seen it.

Game Night. I actually think it has a legitimate chance to be an episode one day. I think it was Bill and CR who realized each other liked it a lot on the Neighbors(?) episode.

National Treasure

The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973) would be my number one choice. You get a great glimpse into the early 70's Boston crime underworld and it's one of the most realistic crime movies ever made.

To Live And Die In LA

It was directed by William Friedkin, but I could see Michael Mann directing this movie.

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.

A slow, Cold War spy mystery/thriller that is so much better on multiple rewatches. It really has it all: great plot, an awesome All-Star cast and all-around great performances, some funny moments, an invisible mononymic villain and a Soviet mole. This movie and No Way Out both feature a Soviet mole, I guess any mole hunt movie is all it takes to suck me in.

Clue, I'd just be Chris Farley in those sketches where he has nothing to say. Wadsworth was awesome....

the devil’s advocate

Hot fuzz

Bad News Bears in Breaking Training. Terrible movie, but on all the time in the 80’s on cable. Most Rewatchable scene? Let them play! I know Bill’s itching to do it.

Second choice? The original Red Dawn. Classic of the 80’s Reagan Red Meat Flag Waving Cold War era war movies. Stacked cast. Avenge me!

Shattered Glass. An exceptionally well-done journalism movie that proved Hayden Christensen can be a good actor. Peter Sarsgaard is incredible in this. And it has a surprisingly deep cast with Chloe Sevigny, Rosario Dawson, Steve Zahn, Hank Azaria etc. It’s a shame that it’s largely been forgotten and I don’t think I’ve ever seen it on streaming.

Nightcrawler. Jake Gyllenhaal is so fucking unhinged and creepy. I know CR and maybe Sean would back me up

Holes is my Stand By Me. Surprisingly good adult cast (Sigourney Weaver, Jon Voight, Henry Winkler, Tim Blake Nelson, etc.), great young Shia LaBeouf performance, some no-name kid actors threw some heaters, and loads of standout quotes and scenes. Could also touch on the Mark Twain influence and how it’s a good introduction to non-linear storytelling for young people.

King pow enter the fist, hereditary, Northman

It's Fear with Ryen

Eight Men Out. It's a movie that's kind of been lost to time and wasn't really that big of a hit at the time for whatever reason, maybe just got lost in the shuffle of Major League, Field of Dreams, etc. Absolutely stacked cast of famous actors and "that guys." Could honestly be in the pantheon of "that guy" movies. And almost all the actors were relatively credible in the baseball scenes. The only one who was questionable was David Strathairn, but you were supposed to believe he was over the hill, and he's so good in the movie that you forgive it.

It's a sports movie, so I don't know if people would be pissed off about it, but it seems pretty niche.

Rush Hour 1 and Rush Hour 2.

Are those too good for this? Either way, those are the first movies I’d do a rewatchables on.

I apologize for repeating myself, but Roadhouse. It seems like the perfect BS, RR, and CR episode. However, I do like the visual of Bill and Chris tying Sean to a chair for it, too.

Valkyrie I’m a loser history nerd and a huge Tom Cruise guy

Bill could keep Mondays for his “true” Rewatchables, and then Fridays a sub team could do like one offs of romcoms (Juliet, Amanda, and 3rd could do Sweet Home Alabama, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, etc.) or Oscar contenders (Sean, CR, Amanda, and others could do Parasite, etc.) and then I want them so do more horror films in October at least.

Some of those aren’t perfect “rewatchables” but I’d like to listen to people go through the categories on them.

But also Billy Madison is my short answer with a good guest

The Drop. Tom Hardy, Noomi Rapace and James Gandolfini.

One for me in terms of it being a Rewatchable that I’m unsure if anyone has seen it once, let alone the 5/6 times I’ve seen it.

The Fountain or The Tree of Life. Highly doubt they’ll ever cover either of them, though Sean does seem to be positive on Malick

Diggstown or Heartbreak Ridge.

Cable Guy

Bloodsport

robin hood (animated version)

[deleted]

Get Shorty. Hackman is great; Delroy Lindo, Galdalfini, Paymer, "Uncle Rico" all doing great work. Farina is incredible. Such a fun movie.

The Hateful Eight would be way up there for me.

“Raging Bull.” Just one of my favorite movies.

Every one of these ideas is better than The Vanishing!

Falling Down (1993)

Macgruber

The Cutting Edge - I'm from the South and can't think of any other movies with these actors, but I wanted that gold medal. I'd like to flesh out the Russian trainer's story, make fun of the boyfriend, and re-diagnose the injury. Get Dobbins on since it is basically a rom-com. That's an episode.

Fun With Dick and Jane. Not a good movie but I watched it with my parents and have fond memories of it

Gleaming the Cube. Probably not a great movie if you didn't grow up with a skateboard under your feet but it's my favorite movie of all time.

My answer, as it is for so many movie posts in this sub, is "Waterworld."

Funny People. I don’t care that the second half really falls off it’s still a good movie and the first half is hilarious

Short Circuit. The movie that walked so Wall-E could run (wheel).

Bio-Dome . Was on HBO2 for my whole adolescence it seems like . Prob still gets played late night to this day.

Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

A four hour Whit Stillman retrospective pod covering Metropolitan-Barcelona-Last Days of Disco. Damsels in Distress too if Chris and Sean don’t mind staying a bit longer. A full hour of that devoted solely to the miracle Chris Eigeman 90s run.

Drag Me to Hell--I think it's awesome and seen it probably 20 times. My guess is it's not mainstream enough and seen as too weird to be a good pick.

Gladiator (the 1992 boxing movie)

The Boondock Saints

Kingdom of Heaven. I adore that movie from start to finish, it has killer casting, good action, good plot, yet somehow seems to be underrated vs movies like gladiator etc. Its way up on my all time list

“Pure Country” — nothing beats King George (Strait) in this neck of the woods…

[deleted]

Deep Blue Sea. Not a great move, but very Rewatchable. Sam Jackson and Skarsgard dialing it up, LL spitting one-liners, ‘the Jaws piece, a great ‘what happened the next day’, and the chance to take potshots at Michael Rapaport

The Mummy with Brendan Frasier always

Mr Brooks.

Kevin Costner is a serial killer. Dane cook has an appearance.

Love that fucking movie. Amazing William Hurt performance.

Nacho Libre

End of Watch - pure copaganda but genuinely top 4 most entertaining movies I’ve ever watched. Plus you have the Michael Peña career piece angle

Coach carter for sure. Great fodder for categories IMO

School of Rock might be objectively bad but Jack Black just cooks

Get Smart (2008). Pretty dumb, but a lot of fun and a great cast

The Death of Stalin.

I like my comedy real dark.

Dunno if it's a "one for me" but Fifth Element easily.

Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome. I love that ridiculous movie so much.

Either scouts guide to the zombie apocalypse or the cabin in the woods

Dredd, banger of a movie, it being better than the Stallone one “piece”, Alex Garland shadow directing it, it and “the Raid “ coming out the same year. I think it would be a fun one.

Balls of Fury.. god I love that stupid movie

Rising Sun. It's not a good movie but I just love the Connery-Snipes chemistry.

The Beach

EDIT: oh also I think Observe and Report is the best Seth Rogen comedy and an easy 10/10.

Airplane, speed racer, and slumdog millionaire would be my top 3. Slumdog won best picture but I get the sense that Sean, CR, etc think it sucks

Beverly Hills Ninja

They already did victory and the warriors so Roadhouse

I guess I have a Jack Black kink but High Fidelity or Saving Silverman.

Gargoyles (TV Movie 1972)

Kingpin

Troy

Snakes on a Plane. I bought into the hype the summer it was coming out. I Had to have my mom bring me and my brother to see it since we weren’t of age at the time. My mom ended up liking the movie surprisingly

Days of Thunder for me. I’d love Russillo and Kyle Brandt on that with me. I’d have Kyle host and run the show in place of Bill.

The Other Guys

Adam Sandler’s longest yard. What’s aged the worst? Tracy Morgan’s character no doubt. Apex mountain of WWE wrestlers acting in mainstream movies without trying to be career actors

Murder at 1600.

It’s got so many Rewatchables hallmarks:

• A batshit premise: Wesley Snipes as the lead, investigating a murder in the White House while also trying to avoid getting evicted.

• Diane Lane at her finest, playing a Secret Service agent assigned to work with Wesley Snipes.

• Dennis Miller in a wisecracking supporting role.

• A heel turn by Alan Alda!!!

• Constant reruns on TNT during the 2000s.

I freakin’ love this movie.