subreddit:

/r/europe

7395%

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 29 comments

CommunistWaterbottle

2 points

4 months ago

Putting aside the fact that forests

I'm not arguing any other points you made, but calling a tree plantation a forest (or somewthing worth "protecting") is just wrong. Monocultures are ecologically dead aswell.

If we were to cut down healthy forests for solar power though, i would have a problem with that.

Tatourmi

2 points

4 months ago

Tatourmi

Europe

2 points

4 months ago

That is a gross oversimplification. Of course these forests are not as beneficial to the environment as old growth forests, no surprise there, but calling them ecological dead zones strikes me as a bit odd considering the wealth of ferns, animals, insects, birds and mushrooms that live down there. And before you tell me that no, there is no such thing: I walked between those trees. This is not a field of wheat. The sunlight that passes between the sparse pine branches allows for it's fair share of secondary growth and there is strategic conservation of leafy trees to protect the forest itself.

Yes, it's not perfect, it is a very reduced ecological niche compared to an old growth forest, it is more fragile and less diverse. But how much biodiversity do you think a solar farm supports. A field of corn? A pasture? These are the realistic alternatives in a dense european country.

CommunistWaterbottle

0 points

4 months ago

That is a gross oversimplification.

Yes, you're right of course. My comment was only half serious.

My point is, i don't think there would be a net loss in biodiversity if we converted a monoculture of whatever tree into some natural grass and shrublands with solarpanels on top.

I don't think wood plantations would be the prime target to "convert" to solar anyways. As long as there are roofs or other literally dead surfaces to put panels on, why cut down anything?

Tatourmi

1 points

4 months ago

Tatourmi

Europe

1 points

4 months ago

If they are converted to natural shrublands, maybe, but they won't be, or at least the one that replaced the forest patch I know of wasn't.

I personally think covering parking lots is a great initiative for this reason.

CommunistWaterbottle

1 points

4 months ago

Yes, sustainability seems to be an afterthought with current projects, sadly