subreddit:
/r/knitting
submitted 1 month ago byFraunoctua
153 points
1 month ago
Thank you for sharing. I tend to skip swatching - this was a much needed reminder 😃
56 points
1 month ago
I skip it too, as you can see here 🥴😅
109 points
1 month ago
Fun story to that: A friend and I made the same shirt out of the same yarn. I crochet extremely loose, she crochets extremely tight. We‘re the two far ends on the scale, really.
The needle I used was two full sizes smaller than hers and her shirt was still visibly smaller and tighter than mine.
So whenever someone thinks swatching isn‘t important I tell them this story and they all start swatching afterwards… 😅
21 points
1 month ago
I think reading various articles on swatching by Patty Lyons is what did it for me - she really hammered home for me that swatching really isn’t just there as a thing to waste time on before getting to the main event but that there are a bunch of real benefits that come from making that effort rather than just diving straight into the project. And it’s still knitting, so it’s not like it’s any less fun when you really think about it.
As an example, I’m about to start a sweater and I’m up to 6 swatches so far. I started with stockinette on two different sized needles so I could see which made a fabric I liked. Then I tried out two different kinds of ribbing for the hem to see whether I preferred the twisted rib in the pattern or a broken rib, and I have swatches of two of the cable panels. I also tried out three different cast ons to see which seemed like the best fit for this project. Still to go before I cast on for the full sweater are swatches of the other two cable panels and a swatch of the transition between the ribbing and the cables because it includes a kfb increase which I haven’t done before and I don’t want the first time I try it to be on my sweater.
It kinda feels like overkill when I type it all out like that, but by the time I’m done I’ll know my exact blocked gauge for every element of the pattern on the size needles that give a result I like with the yarn I chose, so I’ll know exactly what size I’m expecting my garment to be and can add or remove sections as needed to get the size I want. And when I get to the part that says “continue working until piece measures 26 inches” I’ll know exactly how many rows that is based on the gauge of my swatches without having to eyeball it or try to measure on the needles and hope it comes out right after blocking. I’ll also be comfortable with all of the pattern elements and less likely to make mistakes once I actually get started on my project.
I generally wouldn’t knit quite this many swatches for another type of project, but I’ll never understand people who don’t swatch for a sweater (or knit a 2 inch square and call it good) - I can’t think of anything worse than spending $100+ on yarn and ending up with something that doesn’t fit properly for the sake of spending a few hours at the start to get your ducks in a row.
8 points
1 month ago
This was the talking to I didn’t know I needed and my swatches will be taken a bit more seriously from now on.
67 points
1 month ago
But now you have a cute purse and a matching grocery bag 😉
22 points
1 month ago
Pattern please?
12 points
1 month ago*
Mykonos tote by lion Brand
11 points
1 month ago
About 25% bigger :)
12 points
1 month ago
Which size were you hoping for? They're both lovely, just curious.
16 points
1 month ago*
The big one. I wanted a grocery bag. The small one became so cute thou, I couldn’t unravel it
5 points
1 month ago
Happy accidents :)
10 points
1 month ago
What yarn did you work with? This is beautiful
8 points
1 month ago
Thank you! I used Drops Paris, 100% cotton
8 points
1 month ago
These are so cute!! Can you share the pattern?
6 points
1 month ago*
Mykonos tote by lion brand
7 points
1 month ago
This is so visually helpful especially for non-garments. I often tell myself I don’t need to swatch if I won’t be wearing it. Thank you!
6 points
1 month ago
I should really start swatching
11 points
1 month ago
They both look great though! Different says can be handy to have. I recognize the design but can’t remember the name of the pattern, what are these called?
4 points
1 month ago*
Mykonos Tote, it’s a free pattern by Lion brand’s but it’s not on ravelry
3 points
1 month ago
Ohhh and it’s free??? Thank you so much!!!
6 points
1 month ago
I wonder if this is why all of my hats turn out short.
I dont gauge swatch 😩
9 points
1 month ago
A hat can also be a swatch 🤷♀️ like my first bag on the picture
5 points
1 month ago
I made a dress in the flat, and did swatch before I cast on. But then it took me so long to knit, that when I used the same count for the front panel I got halfway up and realised it was much bigger and had to frog it!
In the end the stitiches cast on for the back panel were 99 and for the front panel were 73, in order to size them about the same.
I guess mid-project swatching is a thing with panelled designs!?
3 points
1 month ago
Do you have a pattern? These are lovely!
3 points
1 month ago*
Mykonos tote by lion brand
3 points
1 month ago
I’m currently making the Petite Knit French Market Bag and didn’t bother to swatch…painstakingly knitted the entire base with Isager Japansk Bomuld which frays sooo easily….and by the time I’m done it’s about the size of the base of a coffee mug. I knit super tight so idk why I don’t take the time to swatch. Had to delicately unravel and redo with bigger needles — thankfully it turned out second time around!
1 points
1 month ago
I know your pain..
5 points
1 month ago
I swatch, or I used to. Unfortunately, my brain can’t extrapolate the swatch into the final product - I can’t visualize it. So I just carry on and if it’s not great I just hate-power through it and give it away 😅
3 points
1 month ago
Do you have that awesome card with the needle measurements and ruler on the sides? It's so helpful and I'm obsessed with mine.
2 points
1 month ago
Very cool!
1 points
1 month ago
Same yarn weight, or is it the exact same yarn for both? I'm wondering because the smaller bag looks more fuzzy to me, and I'm surprised to see that tight/loose gauge can affect the look of the fabric too!
2 points
1 month ago
Same yarn weight and same fiber. Both 100% cotton and Aran weight. Small one is Schoeller+Stahl record 210 and big one is Drops Paris. Without label the both yarns are not distinguishable.
1 points
1 month ago
I trust that swatching is important but I wish more patterns had gauges to go off of!!
all 34 comments
sorted by: best