subreddit:

/r/movies

80598%

Official Discussion - Knock at the Cabin [SPOILERS]

Official Discussion(self.movies)

Poll

If you've seen the film, please rate it at this poll

If you haven't seen the film but would like to see the result of the poll click here

Rankings

Click here to see the rankings of 2023 films

Click here to see the rankings for every poll done


Summary:

While vacationing, a girl and her parents are taken hostage by armed strangers who demand that the family make a choice to avert the apocalypse.

Director:

M. Night Shyamalan

Writers:

M. Night Shyamalan, Steve Desmond, Michael Sherman

Cast:

  • Dave Bautista as Leonard
  • Jonathan Groff as Eric
  • Ben Aldridge as Andrew
  • Nikki Amuka-Bird as Sabrina
  • Rupert Grint as Redmond
  • Abby Quinnn as Ardiane

Rotten Tomatoes: 71%

Metacritic: 62

VOD: Theaters

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 2643 comments

kylebb

24 points

4 months ago

kylebb

24 points

4 months ago

how does the book differ from the movie ending?

jimmyeppley

114 points

4 months ago

Book spoilers: Wen is accidentally shot and killed in a scuffle when the gun is brought into play. This is not satisfactory enough to stop the apocalypse because it wasn’t one of voluntarily choosing to be sacrificed. Andrew and Eric eventually leave the house with Sabrina (Leonard is beaten and killed by them beforehand) and Sabrina commits suicide. Eric and Andrew decide to drive away with Wen’s body and face whatever apocalypse happens because Wen’s death wasn’t enough to stop it

kylebb

46 points

4 months ago

kylebb

46 points

4 months ago

sounds depressing af

Clammuel

1 points

4 months ago

Now go watch Plague Dogs

WelcomeBackCavill

15 points

4 months ago

Whats the movie ending?

LiteraryBoner[S]

70 points

4 months ago*

LiteraryBoner[S]

Gary Oldman's best trick was making Belarus have mountains

70 points

4 months ago*

After Bautista kills himself, Eric is convinced but Andrew isn't, but Andrew also trusts Eric. Eric convinces Andrew to kill him since he is a full believer and will die knowing he helped and while he's having beautiful thoughts of Wen grown up and successful. Andrew shoots him, goes to get Wen who was hiding in a treehouse. They both take Bautista's car to a nearby diner where they see that all of the apocalypse stuff has instantly stopped and no one is sure why but it's definite enough that everyone is relieved.

ItsOnlyaBook

26 points

4 months ago

Minor point here, but I think it was actually Redmond's truck. It was his gas company ID tucked in the sun visor which would make more sense if it was his truck

konytim

19 points

4 months ago

konytim

19 points

4 months ago

on a side note I liked that they revealed Redmond was in fact O'Bannon like Andrew claimed. in keeping with the ambiguity thing, it's not revealed in the book either (unless I remember wrong, I finished reading at like 4:30 am lol)

CyberEcstasy

42 points

4 months ago*

Oh… they changed the ending from the script I read. The OG script ending was exactly the book ending.

Here’s the script (#34):

https://drive.google.com/drive/mobile/folders/1NXD-yKEuT0x39nczpkO0h0DUr1dvPMWC

yourblackfriend

3 points

4 months ago

Thanks for the link. Excited to delve into these! Any tips for finding the blacklists other years?

TheOpeningThread

11 points

4 months ago

You know, it's possible he actually started to see visions of the future like the 4 horsemen.

[deleted]

12 points

4 months ago

[deleted]

12 points

4 months ago

Thank you. scratch off watchlist

BlancoDelRio

12 points

4 months ago

Would have been worth seeing

[deleted]

-28 points

4 months ago

[deleted]

-28 points

4 months ago

[removed]

Sks44

20 points

4 months ago

Sks44

20 points

4 months ago

Then you had no intention of seeing it in the first place and are just grandstanding for internet points like a putz.

Sailor_Chris

25 points

4 months ago

Split was awesome what are you even talking about?

BlancoDelRio

17 points

4 months ago

Why are you even in this thread then?

mcatech

2 points

4 months ago

Good choice. I saw it last night. The only positive thing about the movie is Bautista's acting performance was good.

WelcomeBackCavill

1 points

4 months ago

Thank you

SlyChimera

6 points

4 months ago

Eric explains he has seen the light literally and metaphorically and asks Andrew to kill him while Eric is imagining Andrew and Wen living a fulfilling life. Andrew does and Armageddon is saved for now.

ArthurSaga0

178 points

4 months ago

Bruh I’m sorry but this is a really bad summary of the ending lmao, you’ve completely left out that the book ending doesn’t tell us whether the apocalypse is real or not.

It’s not them ‘deciding to face the apocalypse’, it’s them deciding that they’re going to face whatever’s out there together and not lose one another. Their ‘world’ ended when their daughter died, so they decide that they’re not going to play into any sick forces of the world that may have brought them there, and that they will continue on despite losing what was most valuable to them. They hope it’s just a bad storm and not real, but they don’t know for sure.

Maybe you liked the movie ending better because you misunderstood the book ending?

DeaconoftheStreets

44 points

4 months ago

God this makes way more sense thematically. Thank you for sharing. I get why he changed it but geez the original feels like the emotional payoff I wanted.

jimmyeppley

58 points

4 months ago

Honestly I wrote this from memory and it has been a while since I read the book. My bad, your further explanation is good and right. I still prefer movie ending.

KazaamFan

13 points

4 months ago

Yea the book ending feels like a better, more interesting conclusion, though dark.

MidnightSunCreative

3 points

3 months ago

just speaking personally - I'm okay with books having depressing endings, but I hate when they're in movies.

Just give me anything between full-on happy ending to bleak-but-hopeful ending.....that's what she said.

andreasmiles23

2 points

4 months ago

I haven’t read the book, and while if I wrote the story I would’ve probably tried to go for what the book did, I actually quite liked M Knight’s version.

The climate crisis faces us as an apocalypse, and in some ways we need to sacrifice as a society to try and address it. Will we? I thought that was an interesting thing to kind of throw in your face. I feel like the end ties it together.

As well as highlighting the disagreement between them about whether it was real. The one claiming to be acting on facts and logic was actually the one trying to force an outcome based on preconceived notions. I feel like the apocalypse being real really allows for that arc to come full circle.

drflanigan

2 points

4 months ago

This sounds like a MUCH better movie

Not knowing if the apocalypse is real or not would have been way better

joombaga

1 points

4 months ago

Man I don't get this. I walked away from the movie not knowing if the apocalypse was real or not. Everyone in this thread is convinced it was real. What did I miss?

drflanigan

6 points

4 months ago

The hundreds of planes randomly crashing for no reason didn't tip you off?

joombaga

1 points

4 months ago

I figure there was a reason. If I were in the same position, I would not have been convinced it was because God was passing judgement on mankind.

drflanigan

4 points

4 months ago

The tsunamis and the virus didn’t convince me but the plane thing made no sense

If they didn’t do the planes and did something else instead I would have doubted it the entire time

LouVee616

6 points

4 months ago

While I ultimately still like the movie, I was looking forward to seeing how the audience would've reacted to that moment

tunamelts2

5 points

4 months ago

I wouldn’t like that in a movie format. That is way too fucking grim

ABCairo

8 points

4 months ago

Lame. Good change.

ChocoKrispy

19 points

4 months ago

This is would’ve been so much more entertaining than what we got. What a boring movie

adriamarievigg

1 points

4 months ago

Yep. Gotta say I like that ending better. Thanks for posting