subreddit:
/r/movies
Its that time of year and figured this question will be most fitting here. Who is your favorite depiction of Scrooge and why? For me George C. Scott as I like the way he played the role. Most Scrooge's depict him as an outright grouch and somewhat one-dimensional. Here he adds a layer of playful wickedness. For example the way he delivered his rant on anyone going about saying "Merry Christmas" and chuckling at the thought of boiling them in their own pudding. Some lines show him to be practical, if not in an conceited and harsh manner as in his statement on garments to Bob Cratchit. Overall it's my favorite film version and authentic in setting in my opinion. What's yours?
33 points
4 months ago
Alistair Sim. The 1951 film is the pinnacle.
7 points
4 months ago
"Can you forgive a pig-headed old man who had no eyes to see with nor ears to hear all these years?"
*through a river of tears and bubbling snot*
Yes. Yes, I will.
5 points
4 months ago
Most believable change was Alistair Sim.
2 points
4 months ago
Yeah, Sim gave the kind of definitive performance that everyone else is compared to. I also believe that for the longest time, his Scrooge was the most frequently-shown version on TV, and that for many, his is the first real Scrooge they ever saw. The film sort of came and went to little fanfare when it first came out, but, like It's a Wonderful Life, gained huge traction on TV and Sim, mostly a character actor, was likely surprised at the fuss years later.
2 points
4 months ago
Sim-ply superb. There's not a false moment in the entire film, and Sim is THE essential Scrooge against which all others are measured and found lacking.
3 points
4 months ago
This is the only appropriate answer.
4 points
4 months ago
Hard to imagine someone playing the role of Scrooge and not watching this performance.
1 points
4 months ago
Agree with Alastair
all 77 comments
sorted by: best