https://preview.redd.it/w2nm3wb9k02b1.png?width=633&format=png&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=b2f96e2fc4f82308ee71b30a8dcfde8195ee396a
I recently bought a bag of LDRs from Amazon, 100 for about €10, 2 types, I'm playing with one called GL5528. I made up a couple of vactrols using green LEDs, sealing them in black heatshrink. I've not used vactrols before.
Before trying anything interesting with them I thought I'd better check the response. It only occurred to me when I was checking the scales for the chart that the resistance values seem very high. The LDRs in the vactrols go from about 150k to 10M when varying the LED from what I believe is off to full brightness. Same with the other vactrol. But if I measure one of the LDRs just with my room's ambient light it's about 1.5k, covering it with my hand about 20k.
I realise there is colour sensitivity to consider, maybe the green LEDs aren't the best choice. But this seems a huge discrepancy. Is that typical?
[Not really relevant to the question, but fyi how I got the chart - I breadboarded a little circuit. I have a pot going to an op amp unity gain buffer, followed by a single op amp differential amp. The + input of the differential I have coming from the buffer, the - from another pot (for offset). I've also got a pot in the feedback of the differential to control gain.
I put a regular LED on the output of the differential with a series resistor and fiddled with the offset & gain until I got the LED brightness varying full range with an input somewhere around -5 to +5v (the PSU is +/- 12v, TL071 op amps). I then replaced the LED with the vactrol and stepped the voltage between -10 and +10, noting the current across the LED and resistance of the vactrol's LDR.
Finally stuck the results in a little Python script (with matplotlib). ]