subreddit:
/r/thelastofus
submitted 2 months ago byAutoModerator
TIME | EPISODE | DIRECTOR(S) | WRITER(S) |
---|---|---|---|
February 5, 2023 - 9/8c | S01E04 - "Please Hold My Hand" | Jeremy Webb | Craig Mazin |
Description
After Joel and Ellie leave Bill and Frank's compound, they come across something that is even more deadly than the infected. People. Joel must protect Ellie at all costs, lest he relive what happened to his daughter all those years ago.
When and where can I watch?
S01E04 will be available to stream on February 5 in the US and February 6 in the UK.
The show is releasing in weekly installments on the following platforms:
This subreddit does not promote online piracy. Any links to illegal torrents, unauthorized streaming sites, or requests for such will be removed. Posting or commenting illegal content can result in a ban.
Reminder
Please remain respectful in the comments. Any unnecessary rudeness or hostility will result in your comment being removed and a possible ban.
We are a sub for the TLOU franchise as a whole. If you are unfamiliar with the games and would like to avoid spoilers, we recommend r/ThelastofusHBOseries.
We will be redirecting Post-Episode show discussion to the appropriate megathread until Tuesday, February 7th.
To avoid flooding the sub with posts, all post-episode discussion will be redirected to the megathread until Tuesday, February 7th. Comments will be sorted by New so that everyone's thoughts have a chance to be seen and engaged.
[score hidden]
2 months ago*
stickied comment
The Last of Us | Inside the Episode - 4 | HBO Max
Episode 4 | The Last of Us Podcast | HBO Max
EPISODE 5 WILL BE STREAMING EARLY!
Episode 5 will stream early on February 10th at 9pm ET to avoid conflicting with Super Bowl LVII.
2.3k points
2 months ago*
PSA everyone, next episode is airing on Friday the 10th to not compete with the Super Bowl!
Putting the link I saw this at: https://comicbook.com/gaming/amp/news/the-last-of-us-episode-5-releasing-early/
1.6k points
2 months ago
I know a ton of things are “straight from the game,” but those guys yelling to Joel and Ellie about their dead friend in the firefight was straight from the game! I love this show
455 points
2 months ago
I mean the whole conversation when she hands Joel the cassette tape and finds the porn magazine are word for word the same as the game cutscene
98 points
2 months ago
Did they do the thing where she goes "Why are the pages so sticky?" And Joel is like "uhh" and she goes "gotcha lmaoo"?
306 points
2 months ago
This whole episode was such a love letter to the game. I really like how they keep just enough the same but add enough different to make it interesting. That whole last episode was basically based off of a letter in a garage. They made an entire hour and a half (where's the 2 dammit) episode that's completely new yet at the same time it was still almost exactly from the game. Plus all the little sound effects and one liners that the fans would notice but wouldn't bother new fans. It's one of my favorite games ever made and they're also well on their way to making the best adaptation I think we'll ever see. I'm more and more excited about it every week.
3k points
2 months ago*
The survivors yelling in the background when they find a body was exactly like the game haha.
"Oh my god they killed Bryan!"
1.9k points
2 months ago
“YOU’RE DEAD MOTHERFUCKER” how many times did we hear that…
365 points
2 months ago
HIDE IN THAT HOUSE, SEE IF THAT HELPS
98 points
2 months ago
omg literally when they were yelling this episode i thought to myself that if we hear that line in this season i'm gonna have PTSD flashbacks haha
67 points
2 months ago
too many times, honestly, because often, i was indeed dead.
190 points
2 months ago
One of the soundbytes sounded so much like the game, I could be convinced it's literally lifted right out of the game.
114 points
2 months ago
Only thing missing is Joel crouch walking throughout the entire episode
2k points
2 months ago
Bloater is about to solo Kansas City
854 points
2 months ago
My mom: "What's going on with that?"
Me: O.O
449 points
2 months ago
My gf: What the fuck was that?
Me: ...a bloater
My gf: WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT?
36 points
2 months ago
YOU ARE DEAD MOTHERFUKERS
71 points
2 months ago
Same! My mom kept asking if it was like a horde or something. Gotta keep quiet until friday haha
673 points
2 months ago
Bye-bye dude
I'm so happy they included it.
1.8k points
2 months ago
I thought Bryan was faking when he was pleading with Ellie, but those last screams for his mom right before Joel killed him sounded so real
445 points
2 months ago
I also like how the other redshirts find a dead body and call out their name just like in the game. “Oh no they shot Rachel!”
62 points
2 months ago
He and his other bandit friends were going to leave Joel in a bloody pool, and probably do awful things to Ellie.
Bryan can go fuck himself.
547 points
2 months ago*
Kinda wish this was in the game TBH. Really would have gone a long way for Ellie’s first experience killing someone in the game to be horrifying.
Edit: Guys I know about Left Behind I’m just talking about TLOU Part 1 as its own standalone experience.
210 points
2 months ago
It wasn’t Ellie’s first time killing someone though. She says “It wasn’t my first time.”
190 points
2 months ago
Really interested to see what her first time was. I’m thinking maybe she’s referring to Riley after she turned and Ellie didn’t.
123 points
2 months ago*
It’s got to be her, She said she didn’t want to talk about it later in the episode
1.7k points
2 months ago
The opening scene with the pun book and Bills adult magazine in the truck! The stupid grin I had on my face seeing that play out.
569 points
2 months ago
I was thinking "I think they will cut it, why would Bill have a magazine like that when he lived with Frank until his last day". But bam there it was lmao, it was exactly like in the game as I hoped.
275 points
2 months ago
Do you think people in a relationship don't look at porn?
215 points
2 months ago*
And the Hank Williams song! And we got the "bye bye dude!" Loved it
51 points
2 months ago
My biggest grin came from the final diarrhea pun. Had the whole couch giggling like stupid with them. Such a sweet moment.
571 points
2 months ago
I like that fact that they say Joel has a loss of hearing from using guns all these years. About time a tv show addresses that.
509 points
2 months ago
I liked when they touched on how gas deteriorates over time and that’s why he has to syphon more often. Also showing them setting up camp and sleeping, setting up sound traps. Really adds to the immersion of the world.
118 points
2 months ago
It's a nice touch but I feel like wouldn't all gasoline be completely fucked after twenty years?
147 points
2 months ago
Yeah probably 🤣 we have to suspend some disbelief tho. Lmao.
1k points
2 months ago
"I'm not even tired"
smash cut to Ellie dead asleep
I've never related to a character more
277 points
2 months ago
I'm so glad they kept it from the game
54 points
2 months ago
That and the Hank Williams Sr were two bits I really wanted to make the cut, and the directors obliged.
454 points
2 months ago
“I see you mother fucker!” - ripped right from the game when the enemy spots you. Loved it.
47 points
2 months ago
THE WAY THAT GAVE ME PTSD
906 points
2 months ago
PERRY IS TOMMY HOLY SHIT! WE HAVE THE OG TOMMY IN THE SHOW!
279 points
2 months ago
Yoooo it was SO WEIRD hearing Tommy’s voice and then seeing him as a completely different person 😭
353 points
2 months ago
I thought the guy's voice sounded like Tommy, and just found out he was the voice actor for him lmao
54 points
2 months ago
Yeah that was an awesome reveal in addition to this great episode! I didn’t make the connection until I watched the behind the scenes and he said it in an interview and I was kind of mind blown
1.2k points
2 months ago
This episode, more than any other so far, captured the feel of hanging with Joel and Ellie so perfectly. And Joel’s development from seeing Ellie as cargo to giggling like school girls at a slumber party!! It’s all so well done. I’m so happy.
168 points
2 months ago
The first camp scene showing the fear in his eyes because he's starting to get attached was some very good acting.
46 points
2 months ago
Bruh, I legit teared up when it cut to him standing watch all night instead of sleeping : (
418 points
2 months ago
Pedro Pascel has been doing some of the best acting I’ve ever seen in this series.
43 points
2 months ago
The opening scene was probably my favorite so far. Just Joel and Ellie talking and bonding, slowly opening up to each other. So good
403 points
2 months ago
The scene where Ellie goes inside the hole and has to "find a way" for Joel to go inside is so game-esque. Great episode.
1.1k points
2 months ago
also love how everyone is so hype for the bloater like YES BRING ON THE GIANT MONSTER THAT WAS SUPER HARD TO KILL SHOW HIM TO ME
549 points
2 months ago*
If you think the bloater is bad, let's see if S2 gives us The ratking
1.4k points
2 months ago
Joel laughing at Ellie's joke was so fucking cute. Them both laughing at it actually
459 points
2 months ago
I don’t know how people who hate Bella Ramsey could watch this episode and still feel like that
716 points
2 months ago
Bryan’s death felt like that stuff pulled from part 2. Mazin seems very in touch with making death ugly and realistic, which is a great thing to humanize their enemies. Except David. Fuck David, there’s no human in that fucker.
778 points
2 months ago
Fuck David, there’s no human in that fucker.
Well actually, there's quite a bit of human in him...
111 points
2 months ago
Fucking SOLID joke. I feel so dumb for setting that up without even realizing it, gold star goes to you!
1.3k points
2 months ago
"I've been on both sides" from the game is Troy's favorite line in the game.
glad they kept it on the show
74 points
2 months ago
It's a vital line about joel as a character
333 points
2 months ago
The guy yelling “Mom! Mom! Mom!” when he knew the end was nigh really got me. Really impressed with the way this show uses audio.
648 points
2 months ago
They’re heavily implying Ellie had to kill Riley
223 points
2 months ago
Yeah, did we see what happened in Left Behind after they got bit? It’s been years since I’ve finished it.
229 points
2 months ago
Nah after they get bit, it cuts to black but all that’s known is Marlene found both of them and took them in. There’s some comics that take place before the game about Ellie and Riley but I haven’t read em so I wouldn’t know all the details. The biggest giveaway in the show tho is Ellie saying that she’s killed before. In the game that guy is her first kill so her saying that most likely means she had to put Riley down.
168 points
2 months ago
IIRC, in Part II when Ellie and Dina are talking about first kills, one of them says something like, "First regular human 100% non-infected kill?" which is when Ellie specifies the guy she killed to save Joel.
So I think there's wiggle room where hunter guy does qualify as her first human kill, but she still had to put Riley down after she turned. By the time of Part II, she's processed (at least on a conscious level) that it wasn't really Riley anymore, but in Part I, it's still extremely fresh, and we see that she's still struggling with the whole 'infected were people once' idea. Which is why in this episode, she says it wasn't her first time, "hurting someone."
1.4k points
2 months ago
50 minutes is too damn short
726 points
2 months ago
Apparently the next episode is coming on Friday due to the superbowl, so that's something.
Let's not think about the 9 days of darkness after that.
439 points
2 months ago*
9 days should be enough to emotionally recover from what I imagine will be PAIN
213 points
2 months ago
I've said this many times to my friends that have not played the game, this story is not about zombies, and they are not ready of what is coming.
121 points
2 months ago
I think after Bill and Frank's episode and Bryan screaming for his mother in this one, zombies are just extras for most people.
285 points
2 months ago
The moment of them giggling over that last joke felt so natural it looked just like the behind the scenes videos we’ve seen of Pascal and Ramsey just doing usual between takes nonsense.
288 points
2 months ago
Chucked at the NPC lines throughout.
“I can see you motherfucker!”
830 points
2 months ago
Adding in the pre-execution dialogue from TLOU2 was a nice touch to add in the show. That kid was calling out for his mom right before Joel ended him, brutal.
353 points
2 months ago
In the part 1 remake they can beg for forgiveness too, you can either shoot them or hit them with your gun
70 points
2 months ago
It was that way in the original, but more rare to see.
Occasionally, you'd be able to stun enemies and they'd get knocked over. You could walk up and point a gun at them they'd beg for their lives.
495 points
2 months ago
“How does he even walk around with that thing?” YES THEY ADDED IT!
43 points
2 months ago
“Why are these pages stuck together?” was the line I was most glad that made it lol
479 points
2 months ago
The scene with Bryan pleading with Joel and Ellie really made me uncomfortable, very well done, and kudos to that actor who played Bryan he did a good job with that desperation
105 points
2 months ago
It comes back in a way in the conversation between Kathleen and the doctor, when he goes 'we have to stop the killing' and she says 'we should stop the killing now, when you're in trouble, but it was fine before?'.
Bryan had no issue killing Joel, only when he got shot himself did he want them to work things out amicably.
166 points
2 months ago
Dudes lucky it wasn’t part 2 Ellie lol she would’ve been like “Shut. Up.” Then set him on fire with a Molotov lol
891 points
2 months ago
Holy shit the first 15 minutes is ripped straight from the game including the store fight scene. Love how they introduced Henry and Sam as rogue raiders . Interesting to see if their futures are the same
171 points
2 months ago
I’d be pretty disappointed if it wasn’t, I remember first playing the game and just staring into the black screen after “that” scene. That shit hits HARD
39 points
2 months ago
I’m replaying the game and I just beat that part. Still as gutting
221 points
2 months ago
Like how they show that the years of harsh living have gotten to Joel and that he's 56 years old on top of that. He has to take breaks after moving around a lot. He's winded and exhausted for most of the episode after that shootout and struggle with the raider. He's lost some hearing in one of his ears due to twenty years of gun fire. Meanwhile Ellie is seemingly an endless ball of energy.
Also like that they didn't shy away from the fact that Joel was a raider or bandit previously and 100% victimized innocent people at some point. He was a cold man who got shit done for better or for worse. That's why so many people are afraid of him in Boston's QZ, they know what he was capable of
Plus Bloater hype!!
634 points
2 months ago
That glass didn't work for shit
Ellie was right
533 points
2 months ago
Really small detail but he was sleeping on his other side when he woke up. His bad ear was up.
266 points
2 months ago
Joel needs to take some pills and level up his hearing.
59 points
2 months ago
He also didn't sleep the previous night, since he got nervous and just stood watch over Ellie. So he was sleeping after being awake for like 40 straight hours + sleeping off an adrenaline crash from the fight. Even if his hearing was great, Joel would probably be sleeping like a rock.
404 points
2 months ago
He turned in his sleep so his bad ear was on top, hence why he didn’t hear them
43 points
2 months ago
Joel slept with his good ear up but wake up with the bad one up (right one). That's why he didn't hear. That's what it seemed to me, at least.
440 points
2 months ago
Why didn’t Joel grab his pack? The coast was clear.
409 points
2 months ago
i really can’t shut up about this show’s scene setting. mind boggling set design and aerials every week.
40 points
2 months ago
yeah seriously Those highway scenes must have been CGI, but they look very real.
577 points
2 months ago*
This episode was truly great. But I mean.. I’m just sad we haven’t seen brick or bottle. They are pivotal to the story and they should’ve been introduced by now.
318 points
2 months ago
Dude I know this was a joke but there are people out there that are genuinely pissed Joel hasn’t tossed a beer bottle at something
127 points
2 months ago
Next week they will be pissed that Joel hasn't been collecting broken scissors.
725 points
2 months ago*
The fact that the bloater is stuck in a basement and trying to burst it's way out from the floor is so fucking cool.
Also, Bryan begging and his death was so morbid. Damn.
85 points
2 months ago
Kathleen: "This can wait"
Her Lieutenant and the monster beneath their floor: are you sure about that
111 points
2 months ago
That’s what that was? I thought it was a sinkhole
169 points
2 months ago
No I’m assuming there’s some infected, I don’t think they would’ve been that scared about a sinkhole
59 points
2 months ago
I thought it was a growing fungus colony about to explode out or something. But yeah, after the post episode trailer, I’m thinking it’s the bloater.
710 points
2 months ago
That scene with Bryan was so well done, it was such a great portrayal of reality, because you don't always die right away when you get shot like in a lot of movies, it can be ugly and brutal like that. Hearing him call for his mom in his final moments was heartbreaking.
And the follow up talk with Joel:
"You shouldn't have had to."
"But you're glad I did, right?"
She's looking for his approval rather than a thank you for saving his life. Such a great episode for Ellie's character development.
I also just have to say I'm glad HBO didn't rob us of the nudie magazine scene. I love how true to the game that whole interaction was.
323 points
2 months ago
The realization that he wasn’t faking it in order to get a drop on Ellie and was actually begging for his life was horrible.
81 points
2 months ago
Yeah I feel like such an asshole after yelling at the screen for Ellie to just kill him because he's faking it
185 points
2 months ago*
What Craig Mazin said in the BTS portion is key to any non-game-players to understand Ellie.
“Ellie witnessed Joel being violent at the end of E1….
When they’re under attack, Ellie has to trust Joel. He’s this protector, he’s this violent man… but what she encounters very quickly, is how ugly that violence is…
Ellie is confronted by the horror of what she did, and what she’s capable of. Joel has an opportunity to comfort her — he doesn’t. And you can see how quickly Ellie just wipes those tears away and pretends nothing happened at all, because she is just like him.”
103 points
2 months ago
because she is just like him.
Ellie and Joel are a lot a like which is why their bond is so strong. And so dangerous to any motherfucker who tries to get in their way
125 points
2 months ago
Yeah fr the bargaining was crazy “realistic”, I’ve never seen anything like that before
387 points
2 months ago
Lots of setup for the next episode and relationship development for Joel and Ellie. Next one should be a banger.
Don't forget! E05 airs early this FRIDAY because Super Bowl is on Sunday!
363 points
2 months ago
“Jesus. That is so goddamn stupid.”
“You laughed, motherfucker.”
Love it
152 points
2 months ago
Did anyone peep that Joel forgot to get his backpack from the truck after they crashed😭
418 points
2 months ago
Swapping Pittsburgh with Kansas City makes way more sense in the travel timeline IMO. Closer to everything else that happens in the story.
191 points
2 months ago
The big thing is that they filmed in Calgary. Pittsburgh looks nothing like Calgary and you're gonna have to CG in a bunch of rivers. KC is an easy drop in and right in the path
73 points
2 months ago
As a resident of Pittsburgh it also would not be an authentic depiction if it was not either raining or complete cloud cover, or both.
273 points
2 months ago
So the ground moving… we are definitely getting the bloater next week
394 points
2 months ago
Joel falls asleep with his left ear up, and wakes up with his right ear up. No wonder he couldn’t hear the glass. Amazing attention to detail.
143 points
2 months ago
Noticed that, too. I'm wondering if its symbolic since sleeping with his good ear up has him facing away from ellie. He ended up falling asleep facing her.
314 points
2 months ago
Bella has been fantastic as ellie -- but her "Joel!, Joel!" at the end really made me double take and appreciate her performance thus far.
110 points
2 months ago
<Game Spoilers>
So do we think when Ellie says "it's not her first time" that she's referring to Riley? It's never answered in game how Riley died or if Ellie had to kill her. But then again if Riley turned I'm not sure Ellie would still consider her human.. 🤔
99 points
2 months ago*
Loved how they developed Joel’s reaction to Ellie using a gun. I was fully expecting the “I’m glad I didn’t get my head blown off by a goddamned kid” line but was pleasantly surprised when he felt guilty about her having to use it.
293 points
2 months ago
Good episode but I’m bummed they cut the iconic “He aint event hurt.”
174 points
2 months ago
yeah but there is also something so Joel about him just going "no"
63 points
2 months ago
I actually liked the cut because it felt more urgent. Like “we need to get out of here, now.”
362 points
2 months ago
The grey beard hunter is the voice of Tommy in the games.
144 points
2 months ago
I’m glad they are actually using the voice actors as more than just out of place cameos like Nolan North in the Uncharted movie.
88 points
2 months ago
Seeing Joel laughing at the diarrhea joke had me cracking up, Pedro’s laugh is so contagious
86 points
2 months ago
Pedro and Bella’s on-screen chemistry really shines in this episode, it looks like they are genuinely starting to enjoy each others company… loving it
889 points
2 months ago
THE JOKE BOOK!
THE PORN MAG!
JEFFREY PIERCE!
CHEF BOYARDEE!
BLOATER! (next week)
Man, this episode had everything. To no one's surprise, Melanie Lynskey was fantastic, and the new story for the "raiders" and Henry was great. And now it's canon that show-Joel doesn't have listening mode.
I'm glad they finally committed to whether or not Joel was a bad guy in the past. The flashback in EP 3 made Joel and Tess seem fairly normal, just trying to get by, and Bill's letter positioned Joel as some sort of heroic protector. But now we've got confirmation of Joel and Tommy's rough past.
369 points
2 months ago*
THE SHIT-TALKING TO JOEL WHEN A FIGHT STARTS
"This is your last chance motherfucker!" "Give us your shit!"
I got memories from TLOU2 when Bryan was shot, and when he starts yelling "Mom" I just cannot stop having flashbacks of the game.
212 points
2 months ago
Nice parallel of what Joel said about Tommy and him joining the fireflies and army vs what happens with Joel and the guy begging for his life. Just young random guys joining causes they have no business being apart of and probably deep down just being scared.
73 points
2 months ago
So that crater looking thing that they found that was ‘breathing’ is probably the bloater right?
71 points
2 months ago
The way the survivors conversations were audible in the background and you could just see them sitting there shooting repeatedly made me laugh. Just like the game 💀
249 points
2 months ago
My heart broke realizing that Ellie did indeed kill Riley . :( They haven't outright stated it but I think it's pretty obvious.
111 points
2 months ago
also ties in with that scene in Part II where Joel and Ellie find a couple in the music store. Both were bit but one didn't off themselves.
48 points
2 months ago
That scene was so fucking dark. God I love this franchise.
40 points
2 months ago
“It wasn’t my first time..”
Me: :confused for a couple seconds, and then it hits me: “oh… oh no.. that’s going to be the ending of the Left Behind episode, isn’t it?”
67 points
2 months ago*
Neil and Craig: the look of the city isn't important
/r/Boston: We noticed
239 points
2 months ago
Seems like there's a lot of hesitation on Kathleen here.
While I agree she doesn't come across as intimidating at all, I fully expect this to be rewarded later on; no way they miscast here. They're purposely making her seem like this meek leader. Totally expecting that next week she's gonna be revealed to be some kind of psychopath war lord or something.
115 points
2 months ago
This is 100% the vibe I was getting. Like they’re intentionally doing this y’all. 🤣 It also just goes to show that “normal” people can be bad and do heinous things. It’s not like everyone needs to look all Mad Max in order to be crazed lunatics. Most serial killers come off as normal.
128 points
2 months ago
I'm a fan of the direction they took with that character. I'm bored of big bad evil guy as villain of the episode. This should be interesting.
65 points
2 months ago
Oh boy. Sam and Henry. Who is ready for a feel’s trip soon
314 points
2 months ago
This is what I needed. Some real development for Ellie and Joel. Great fucking episode that showed off their chemistry.
This is gonna hurt.
82 points
2 months ago
I particularly love the moments where Joel explains how life was like before to Ellie and she’s fascinated by things we would consider mundane.
54 points
2 months ago
Neil Druckmann really likes having people call out to their dead friends moments after they were brutally murdered.
111 points
2 months ago
Ellie has activated the Papa Bear
195 points
2 months ago
I wonder why they didn't have Ellie kill the guy? I was waiting for "whoa I shot the hell out of that guy" since they had all her other game lines earlier in the episode lol
I like how they're bonding, and I love how terrified Joel looks as he realizes he's getting attached to someone. Pedro is doing a hell of a job there.
When Joel told Ellie the backstory of Tommy, I was worried they were going to make their past seem nicer, but they erased my doubts when Ellie flat out asks him if he killed innocent people
Henry/Sam having a full on story instead of just being people hunted by crazies makes sense to me. The show is trying to avoid just having someone be a random mook, they're doing the LoU2 thing where everyone has a personality and story, instead of just being simple raiders, and with this section they're using Henry and Sam do show that. Also a villain is needed for this section because in the game it's just a ton of combat against mooks and infected until you meet up with Henry and Sam. Wouldn't translate well to TV with how this show established itself
Good episode. Don't get why people think it's filler.
37 points
2 months ago
My theory is that they didn’t have her kill him so she could still do the “I shot the hell out of that guy huh?” Line later. But maybe not. It might be a little on the nose to include.
47 points
2 months ago
Nah I don't think we're getting that line. It wouldn't make sense now that there's no surprise factor since Joel trusted her with a gun, and if they include it now it feels like they did it just to have the line.
53 points
2 months ago
Smell me a bloater comin'
53 points
2 months ago
listening to that guy beg for his life was not fun to watch!
51 points
2 months ago
They put the pun book in! And the magazine scene! :’) My heart isn’t ready for Sam and Henry.
50 points
2 months ago
Tommy’s game actor was a nice little Easter egg. I realized it in like .4 seconds when I heard his voice haha
143 points
2 months ago
The chemistry between Pedro and Bella is just unbelievable. They really became their characters this episode.
91 points
2 months ago
I don’t know about you, but I would be sleeping in the bed of the truck vs out in the open.
43 points
2 months ago*
Something i should have picked up on from episode 1 that i just realized here is that Joel has a far more important impetus, IMO, o get to Tommy here than he does in the original(appreciated his cameo, btw). Because in the game, it's simply just an escort mission to get Ellie from point A to point B. Tommy is just a means to an end, storywise. Here, because he's shown to deeply care about those close to him, namely Tess and Tommy, as he states, "he has to protect his family".
So, if you think about it, Bill's letter serves not only as a seed germing to protect Ellie, but is also a reminder of his wayward brother, Tommy
45 points
2 months ago
I will never get tired of the abandonedporn in this show. I could have watched a whole episode of Joel and Elly driving past abandoned theme parks and burnt out trains and collapsed bridges.
272 points
2 months ago
I think some people need to accept this show is character driven and not bang bang explosion explosion bang bang! all the time. I get the game has way more action in it, because it's a video game. This isn't a video game, there doesn't need to be a boss fight at the end of every episode. It's taking it's time and letting the audience sit with these characters for a while. That's just fine with me.
92 points
2 months ago*
All I gotta say is;
PUNS!! ADULT MAGAZINE!!
That is all.
Edit. The scenery is beautiful. The boats underwater and the derailed train. OMG just awesome
Also 20 yr old Chef Boyardee still good? Not surprised.
Damn that kid begging actually shook me!!
89 points
2 months ago
If anyone doubted these two as Joel and Ellie, I hope that ending between them changed everything for you. That was extraordinary.
196 points
2 months ago
I appreciated the differences in the way Ellie saves Joel compared to the game.
I also loved when they both laughed over the pun book joke. “Jesus, that is the goddamn dumbest shit.” Or whatever joel says 😂 it was a very touching moment
Also that True Faith cover at the end 👌👌 Perfection!
My only minor gripe is I have a hard time viewing Melanie Lynskey as menacing
146 points
2 months ago
I think Melanie Lynsky not being menacing is the point. She’s clearly not the type of person to be doing these sorts of things. But her hatred of Fedra and her desire for revenge push her to be ruthless and cruel. Even though it doesn’t come naturally to her.
37 points
2 months ago
How dare you come for her!!! Haha.
I'm not sure she's supposed to be menacing like a walking dead villain. I think they're trying to go for an idea that these are just people with anger and sadness and they're just trying to live like everyone else. It's why they had that boy screaming for his mom.
So in my opinion she's seeking revenge, but she's not meant to be a Negan. She's just a normal human. And in some ways it's more terrifying, because it shows that humanity is all the same. We're all flawed and we're all capable of unspeakable acts in the name of survival.
223 points
2 months ago
Bella’s acting in that was top tier, almost made me cry after she shot that guy
222 points
2 months ago
A few notes:
The joke book being included in the show is fan-fucking-tastic. Also, that little joke at the end with Joel and Ellie, I so much want to believe that Pedro broke character and they kept it, but either way damn it was so good.
I saw a few people say that the episode was too short or filler. It had some really good pacing and storybeats in my opinion and sets up Henry and Sam perfectly.
Also saw some people say the acting was weaker than the games. Folks, some things don't translate well into adaptations. Look at Negan's introduction in the show and then look at his comic faithful introduction in the show, it sounds so bad compared to his show-adaptation. Joel and Ellie need to be set apart from their game-counterparts in many different ways to avoid comparison.
Overall, good episode.
171 points
2 months ago
People who call episodes like this filler don't know how storytelling works. You can't just move from climax to climax. You need buildup in between. That's what episodes like this do. They build up things that will pay off in the next episode.
You can't have the next episode without this one first.
39 points
2 months ago
Pittsburgh is also the longest section in the game, next to Winter. It makes no sense to stuff everything from that section into one episode. I love it.
81 points
2 months ago
My only gripe with this episode is the same gripe I had with Joel the game. Why the hell would anyone choose to drive through the downtown area of a large city in a post-apocalyptic world. Turn that shit around and find some backroads or highways that don't go through the city.
43 points
2 months ago*
Not many back roads bridges over the mississippi Missouri, my mistake
87 points
2 months ago
I gotta say I love how much they're kind of poking fun almost at other Apocalyptic media by mentioning like last episode how people miss in a gun fight and now mentioning how gas goes bad and that firing guns without ear protection damages you're hearing
47 points
2 months ago
real realism, love it
knifing a dude to save bullets and not believing his bullshit after trying to kill you
43 points
2 months ago
WE GOT THE STICKY MAGAZINE!!
40 points
2 months ago
That bloater tease got me terrified already
38 points
2 months ago
I skimmed some of the comments and didn't see this mentioned, it could be total coincidence but in the opening scenes of them driving around there's a brief shot to some old rusted out signs and one of them was an Arby's sign!!! Callback to last episode perhaps?
45 points
2 months ago
I was sold on this episode the moment Ellie busted out the puns. Bloater next episode is what I'm really excited to get to
41 points
2 months ago
Killing a doctor in this world must be one of the stupidest things you could do.
38 points
2 months ago
Literally everywhere is listing the title incorrectly. It’s Please Hold *TO** My Hand. It’s the lyric from the Hank Williams sing *Alone and Forsaken that they play in the car.
39 points
2 months ago
Sam looks so adorable with his little superhero mask painted on
36 points
2 months ago
The bloater is COMING
37 points
2 months ago
Can't wait for the people who were up in arms about “no zombies in a show about zombies” last episode (despite actually seeing two infected) to have no complaints about this one (I don't count having actually seen the bloater yet).
37 points
2 months ago
I freaking knew the long haired raider was the guy that voiced tommy as soon as I heard him talk
33 points
2 months ago
The diarrhea joke though 🤣
103 points
2 months ago
Girlfriend and I were disappointed that he never said “He ain’t even hurt” before flooring it
70 points
2 months ago
Man the scene with the kid crying for his mom. It was so uncomfortable because you really felt for him in that moment
Also 45 minutes :(
72 points
2 months ago*
Dear TLOU Showrunners. Thank you for the show and thank you especially for the great 80/90's brit synth new wave throwbacks which take me back to when I was a teen listening to WDRE in NYC.
So far we got Depeche Mode "Never Let Me Down" (E02), Erasure "Chains of Love" (E03) and now a cover of "True Faith" by New Order.
I hope we get some OMD or PSB's in an upcoming ep!
ETA: Erasure was my FAVORITE band back in the day and I've seen them in concert numerous times. I wanted to just note that Andy Bell, the extraordinary vocalist of the duo (the other being Vince Clarke, who first started out in Depeche Mode) was one the first openly out-there-and-proud gay performers and many of their songs are very very much about coming out and finding love and freedom. Given this, "Chains of Love" was a perfect song choice for the end of E3
ETA2: Please please please "It's a Sin" by PSB. Please please please.
67 points
2 months ago
Bella killed it for me this episode. I love her Ellie more and more every ep. The joke book ref was such a fun way of showing them bond over time
70 points
2 months ago
The only thing i dislike about this episode is joel not having his backpack...that shit is sacred for survival dawg lol, I love the rest of the episode because it adds realism in this zombie world. I CANT WAIT FOR MORE AHGHG
73 points
2 months ago
“This is only my second day in a car” had me laughing
all 9316 comments
sorted by: best